Lehigh Valley/ Real Estate & Development

Bethlehem Data Center Plan Called Incomplete Over Lenape Site Concerns

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Bethlehem Data Center Plan Called Incomplete Over Lenape Site Concerns3700 Commerce Center Blvd. — Approximate Site of Proposed Data Center
Google Street View

A sprawling, two-story data center proposed for Bethlehem's Commerce Center Boulevard has hit a snag with regional planners, who say the application is missing too much information to properly evaluate it. The project, pitched by Bethlehem Earth LP for a site at 3700 Commerce Center Boulevard, would rise 80 feet tall with a 402,500-square-foot footprint and a 123,750-square-foot electrical substation area on land that once belonged to Bethlehem Steel.

Reports on the project's total size diverge: according to WFMZ.com, the facility would total 805,000 square feet, while The Morning Call puts the figure at 800,000 square feet. Bethlehem Earth LP is registered to an address in Jenkintown, Montgomery County, and the development plan also calls for parking, stormwater facilities and related infrastructure, along with a separate 20.7-acre property at 3200 Commerce Center Boulevard that would provide access and utility connections.

Lehigh Valley Planning Commission Flags Missing Details

The Lehigh Valley Planning Commission's Comprehensive Planning Committee discussed the proposal this week and ultimately amended its review letter to label the application incomplete. The committee's concerns centered on missing information about energy usage, water usage, noise and environmental impacts, the same report notes. LVPC Chief Planner Jill Seitz said the application lacked details on the anticipated electrical load and potential noise, vibration and air-quality impacts, according to the outlet's reporting.

LVPC planners separately wrote that the proposed generator yards, electrical substation, water infrastructure and cooling systems are integral parts of the development, and that their operational characteristics and associated impacts must be understood to properly evaluate the project. Planners also identified missing projected energy use, cooling technology, employee count, and noise and air-emission mitigation details. Even so, planners said the data center would be generally compatible with its surroundings, noting the proposed sites sit in Bethlehem's industrial zoning district next to an existing industrial park whose tenants include McKesson, GXO and Crayola.

Concerns Over a Lenape Cultural Site

Beyond the technical gaps, the committee added language recognizing the possible harm of the data center to a significant cultural site to the Lenape people, the same report states. The committee's amended letter strongly recommends the applicant provide the city with additional information before the project moves forward. LVPC commissioner Chris Amato put it bluntly, saying, “There are too many unknowns for this to even remotely be considered a complete application.”

The full LVPC was set to consider the review at its Thursday evening meeting, though the commission's role is strictly advisory. The LVPC makes only nonbinding recommendations, and it is the city of Bethlehem's planning commission that holds final authority to approve or reject the project. Bethlehem's Deputy Director of Planning and Zoning, Craig Peiffer, said the city planning commission could consider the proposal as early as December 10, or on January 14 if it misses that agenda.

A Second Bethlehem Data Center Already Has the Green Light

The Commerce Center Boulevard proposal is not the only data center working through Bethlehem's approval process. The Bethlehem Planning Commission approved plans for a separate two-story data center less than a week before this review, clearing the way for a facility at 2184 Industrial Drive, next to Route 22, on a site that was formerly home to Crowder Service Center. That previously approved plan calls for a 65,590-square-foot, two-story, 120-megawatt data center on a six-acre site in Lehigh Valley Industrial Park I.

Developers behind the Industrial Drive project previously told lehighvalleylive.com that the facility would use a closed-loop water cooling system and draw 120 megawatts of power. A separate LVPC report found that more than $70 million in electrical and utility infrastructure upgrades could be needed for that project, with the costs expected to be privately funded, according to Lehigh Valley Public Media. Notably, both the Commerce Center Boulevard and Industrial Drive proposals were submitted before the city had specific data-center regulations on the books, meaning both will be reviewed under the zoning guidelines that predate those rules.

Part of a Broader Land-Use Debate

The scrutiny in Bethlehem reflects a wider reckoning across the region. LVPC planner Jillian Seitz has said data centers, particularly large-scale facilities, are now the primary land-use concern in Lehigh County, according to LehighValleyNews.com. The LVPC's Transportation Committee has been reviewing a draft Industrial Land Use Guide that identifies electricity and water needs, emergency-response coordination and environmental impacts such as cooling-equipment noise as key planning considerations for communities weighing these projects.

Other proposals in the pipeline underscore the scale of the trend. A data center proposed for 1024 North Bradford Street in Allentown was described as a 146,000-square-foot project, while a proposed South Whitehall facility could have a peak electricity demand of more than 700 megawatts, Lehigh Valley Public Media has reported. For now, the fate of the Commerce Center Boulevard project rests with Bethlehem officials, who will decide whether Bethlehem Earth LP's plans move forward once — or if — the missing details the LVPC flagged are filled in.