
A Facebook Marketplace meetup to sell a bracelet and chain near Hempstead Turnpike and Randal Drive in Bethpage turned into an armed robbery, according to Nassau County police, who say two Bronx men have now been arrested and charged in connection with the September heist. No one was hurt, but the 23-year-old seller watched as a firearm was displayed and his jewelry was taken without payment.
According to longisland.com, the victim had arranged to sell an item through Facebook Marketplace in the vicinity of Hempstead Turnpike and Randal Drive, and the meetup occurred on Sunday, September 6, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. Police said two men displayed a firearm before taking the bracelet and chain jewelry he was selling, according to Patch. No injuries were reported at the scene, per the same account from longisland.com.
Arrests Came Weeks Apart
Alexander Herrera Cedano, 27, was arrested on September 16 and charged with first-degree robbery, police said. He was arraigned the following day, September 17, at First District Court in Hempstead, per Patch's report. Separately, as reported by Daily Voice, Cedano was later released on bail and is due back in court Tuesday, December 8.
The second suspect, Yorky Cleto Aquino, also 27, wasn't arrested until Thursday, November 12 — more than two months after the robbery — and was charged with first-degree robbery as well, the same Patch article notes. He was arraigned the day after his arrest, on November 13, at First District Court in Hempstead. Daily Voice reports Aquino was held on bail figures that included $5,000 cash, a $10,000 bond, or a $25,000 partially secured bond, and that he is due back in court Tuesday, December 15.
Both Men Reportedly Tied to Separate Bronx Cases
Daily Voice reports that both men live in the Bronx, and that records show names and ages matching each suspect to separate, unrelated Bronx criminal cases. Cedano's name and age reportedly match a man facing a separate Bronx robbery case tied to an April 24 incident, with a next court date listed as January 20, according to Daily Voice. Aquino's name and age reportedly match a Bronx criminal case tied to his November 12 arrest, with a top charge of third-degree possession of a forged instrument, per the same outlet.
A Pattern Playing Out Beyond Long Island
Online marketplace meetups turning violent isn't unique to Bethpage. In Franklin, Tennessee, police said a Facebook Marketplace jewelry sale was connected to an alleged armed robbery at a northeast Franklin home on October 9, 2026, according to fox17.com. Three men in that case faced charges including aggravated robbery, felony evading, and tampering with evidence, the station reported, and that investigation remains ongoing.
Anyone following the Nassau County case can check for future court appearance dates in criminal and family court matters through the state's free case lookup tool, according to the NY Courts - Unified Court System WebCivil eCourts page.









