
Before you click buy on that Black Friday deal, you might want to check what the item cost back in September. New price-tracking research suggests that some of this year's biggest markdowns followed weeks of quiet price increases, meaning the discount shoppers see at checkout may not be the bargain it appears to be.
According to a report from News4JAX, the e-commerce price-tracking firm Decodo monitored prices on roughly 1 million items from 37 U.S. retailers and found that many retailers raised prices on tracked items by an average of 30% as early as September, weeks ahead of Black Friday, before lowering them again for the sales event. Gabrielė Vitkė, an analyst at Decodo, told the outlet her team began monitoring prices in fall 2025 and found that Black Friday deals often follow price increases that happened weeks earlier.
One example the station cited was a Ryobi 18V ONE+ 6-tool kit, which was priced at $79 in September 2025 before climbing to more than $200 in the months that followed. By Black Friday, the kit was marked down 51% to $99 — technically a steep discount, but still about 25% higher than its September price, per the same report.
A KitchenAid Mixer's Bouncing Price Tag
A similar pattern showed up with a KitchenAid stand mixer sold at Target. The News4JAX report says the mixer's price repeatedly shifted between $499.99 and a sale price of $349.99 throughout 2026, and as of November 10, it was back up to $499.99 — leaving its eventual Black Friday 2026 price unclear at the time of that reporting.
That same model had already drawn attention earlier in the month. On Nov. 2, MassLive reported the KitchenAid 5-Qt 10-Speed Stand Mixer was selling at Target for $349.99, down from $499.99 — a $150, or 30%, discount.
Electronics Climbing Even With Discounts
Vitkė also told News4JAX that electronics prices have risen considerably, and Decodo's tracking shows electronic goods are more expensive in 2026 than they were in 2025 — meaning even a Black Friday markdown might still land higher than what shoppers paid a year earlier.
Decodo's broader research backs up the idea that online prices shift constantly and that those swings make it harder for shoppers to spot a genuine deal. In a separate analysis of more than 150,000 price observations across 37 major U.S. e-commerce retailers, the company's Vitkė described a pattern where retailers temporarily inflate prices before presenting the original regular price as a limited-time deal, according to Decodo's own pricing analysis. That same research found fashion price changes surged in October — 688 changes tracked for women's items and 247 for men's — before dropping sharply in early November to 188 and 82 changes, respectively.
Not Every Deal Is a Dud
The picture isn't uniformly bleak for shoppers. In a separate Decodo study tracking more than 430 products from Black Friday 2025 through early December, 111 items — about one in four — actually got cheaper after Black Friday ended, with an average additional discount of 34.55%. The same analysis found that 74% of tracked products hit their lowest price on Black Friday itself, suggesting the sales event often does deliver the best price of the season, even if not always.
Pet supplies were the exception in that sample: 67% of tracked pet products increased in price after Black Friday, and none became cheaper, Decodo found. Other independent research points to similar inconsistency. Visualping monitored more than 2,600 products during the 2025 holiday season and found that roughly one-third of Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals had actually been available for less earlier in the season, priced an average of 37% higher than the lowest prices the firm recorded between October 1 and Cyber Monday, according to ConsumerAffairs.
What Other Trackers Have Found
WalletHub data cited by CNBC found that 36% of items on sale for Black Friday offered no savings at all compared with how they were priced between Oct. 27 and Nov. 17, though items that were genuinely discounted saw an average markdown of about 24%. Consumer savings expert Andrea Woroch told the outlet that retailers constantly fluctuate prices and may simply repackage an item that was already discounted and call it a Black Friday sale.
Groundwork Collaborative, reviewing more than 350 products Amazon advertised as deals, found that 29.1% were priced the same or higher during the sale than in the month leading up to it, per the Groundwork Collaborative report. Across the Atlantic, the consumer group Which? compared 175 home, tech and health appliances at eight major retailers and found 83% were cheaper or the same price on at least one occasion outside the four-week Black Friday sales window last year, as reported by The Independent. Not every category showed the same pattern, however — DataWeave's monitoring of nearly 80,000 products found consumer electronics discounts averaged 14.6% in the run-up to Black Friday, with only an additional 2.6% average discount during Black Friday Week itself, according to its 2025 analysis.
What the Rules Actually Require
Federal guidance offers some context for how former-price comparisons are supposed to work. Under 16 CFR § 233.1, the Electronic Code of Federal Regulations states that advertisers should be especially careful that a former price was openly and actively offered for a reasonably substantial period in the recent, regular course of business, honestly and in good faith, and not established simply to create a fictitious comparison price. That standard doesn't determine whether any specific retailer's current pricing crosses a line — it simply outlines what a legitimate former-price comparison is supposed to look like.
For shoppers trying to sort real deals from recycled price tags, Vitkė's advice is straightforward: set a price alert for items on a wish list so you're notified when a price actually drops, rather than relying on a sale sticker alone. Decodo's research confirms that retailers frequently change prices online, which Vitkė says makes it harder for shoppers to identify genuine deals — making it worth checking what an item cost a few months earlier before deciding whether Friday's price is really a bargain.









