Inland Empire/ Crime & Emergencies

Bloomington Man Gets Death Penalty, First Since Newsom's Mass Commutation

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Bloomington Man Gets Death Penalty, First Since Newsom's Mass CommutationCounty Courtroom
Tim Mossholder / Unsplash

A Riverside County judge sentenced Saul Arevalo Jr., 43, of Bloomington, to death on Thursday for the 2016 murders of three Lake Elsinore residents, marking the first death sentence handed down in California since Gov. Gavin Newsom commuted every sentence on the state's death row. A jury found Arevalo guilty following a three-month trial for the killings of Cameron Craven, 55, Robert Kirchman, 57, and Rachel Rupp, 31, before determining in a separate penalty phase that he should die for the crimes.

According to KESQ, the murders occurred inside the victims' Lake Elsinore home on Aug. 2, 2016. Arevalo had been tasked with collecting a debt from one of the men, and he and an accomplice had first entered the home on July 31, 2016, assaulting two of the men. He returned early on Aug. 2 with three accomplices, all wearing construction vests in an apparent attempt to avoid drawing suspicion, the station reported.

Surveillance Camera Unplugged Before the Shooting

Arevalo unplugged a surveillance camera before entering the home with a firearm and shooting all three victims, the station's report states. He also shot the victims' dog. Trial evidence included surveillance footage, cellphone records placing Arevalo near the home during both the July 31 and Aug. 2 incidents, and evidence connecting him to the truck used by the suspects, per the same account.

Arevalo did not testify during the trial, but the outlet's report notes he admitted during a recorded interview to being at the home, before later trying to distance himself from the surveillance footage. He also asked his wife to provide him with an alibi, according to the report. Jurors in the guilt phase weighed whether Arevalo committed the murders and whether special-circumstance allegations applied before convicting him; in the penalty phase, they considered aggravating and mitigating evidence before settling on death.

Families Address the Court at Sentencing

Members of each victim's family were present for sentencing and read victim impact statements to the court, the station reported. Arevalo also addressed the victims' families before the judge formally imposed the death sentence. The Riverside County District Attorney's Office announced the sentence.

First Death Sentence Since Newsom's Historic Commutation

The sentence lands just weeks after Newsom commuted death sentences for 548 state prisoners, a move CalMatters describes as the largest act of mass clemency in U.S. history, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. California has not actually executed a prisoner since Arnold Schwarzenegger was governor, per the outlet's reporting. In a letter released by the Office of the Governor of California, Newsom said he planned to change all California death sentences to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

Arevalo's case now stands as a fresh addition to death row even as the governor's broader plan to end capital punishment in practice moves forward. CalMatters also points to a University of Miami study covering California death sentences from 1987 to 2019, which found that Riverside County hands down a disproportionate share of the state's death sentences — a pattern this latest case, out of a Riverside County courtroom, fits squarely within.