
Five rental cottages could soon rise on a half-acre lot on South Wilson Street in Boise's Bench neighborhood, but a group of neighbors isn't ready to let the project move forward without a fight. They've appealed two city approvals tied to the Wilson Cottage Court development, pushing the dispute toward a possible hearing before Boise City Council.
Planning and Zoning approved a conditional use permit and variances for the property last week, according to Idaho News 6. That decision wasn't about whether five homes could be built on the site at all — it dealt with narrower details, including where parking could go, how much landscaping would be required, and how far the cottages would need to sit from the property line. With neighbors now appealing, the conditional use permit could head to the City Council for further review, though no hearing date or outcome has been set.
Parking And A Shrinking Buffer At The Center Of The Fight
Part of what's being appealed is a variance that would shrink a landscape buffer from five feet down to about three feet, eight inches, per the same report. The project's parking plan technically exceeds Boise's baseline requirement of one space per cottage, but the property comes with its own constraints. According to the developer, a 30-foot irrigation district easement eats up much of the lot's north side, limiting exactly where a driveway and parking spots can be placed. Property owner Guy Skeele said those restrictions make it difficult to add extra parking for storage needs or visitors.
Neighbor Bob Johnson isn't convinced the numbers add up for a street like Wilson. “Five is too much. Take it down to three, we could live with it,” he said, according to the station's report. Johnson also argued that the underlying zoning code needs to be revisited, saying the project would simply fit better with three cottages instead of five. Katherine Barker pointed to a more immediate headache: Wilson Street is a narrow one-way road that dead-ends, and she said outside traffic already turns around in residents' private driveways.
A Garage Access Dispute Adds To The Tension
The disagreement isn't limited to parking and setbacks. A family next door uses a building on the property as a garage, reaching it by crossing part of the lot. The developer has said there's no recorded easement giving them that access, and the two sides reportedly have not worked out an agreement. Chris Scuglia, from that neighboring family, said simply that they like their neighborhood, while Erin Scuglia said the family plans to carve out some parking in front of their home and adapt to whatever comes next.
Erin Scuglia also voiced the broader frustration shaping the appeal, saying the project seems unreasonable for the size of the property and the street it sits on, even as she acknowledged the region's housing affordability struggles. Neighbors have been careful to frame their objection as being about scale and site conditions, not a blanket rejection of new housing. Skeele, for his part, said he's trying to add housing within the rules the city has set while keeping the market-rate rentals as affordable as he can, and he said he hopes neighbors can find a way to get along and be good neighbors going forward.
Part Of A Wider Push For Infill Housing
The Wilson Cottage Court fight is playing out as Boise looks for ways to add more housing inside existing neighborhoods, including cottage-style developments like this one. A similar concept has surfaced across town, where a proposal for 15 small cottage homes, each under 1,000 square feet, was floated for two parcels in the historic Ustick Townsite, according to BoiseDev. That proposal was submitted only for early city review and was not yet formal, meaning it could still change.
Neighborhood pushback against Boise infill projects has escalated into formal legal fights before. The Londoner Neighborhood Association sued after the City Council voted 3-2 in March to approve a project near Broadway Avenue featuring 189 apartments in a three-story building with 232 surface parking spaces, affirming an earlier Planning and Zoning Commission approval, BoiseDev reported. Under the City of Boise's own guidance, an affected person may seek judicial review in District Court once local remedies are exhausted, and any such appeal must be filed within 28 days of the city's final action.
For now, the Wilson Cottage Court dispute remains at the city level, with neighbors hoping the appeal forces a second look at a project they say was sized for the wrong street. Whether the conditional use permit ultimately reaches the City Council, and what residents along Wilson Street can expect if it does, remains to be seen.









