Greater Hartford/ Crime & Emergencies

Bridgeport Man Extradited From Nicaragua in Mother's 2025 Porch-Baby Shooting

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Bridgeport Man Extradited From Nicaragua in Mother's 2025 Porch-Baby ShootingSource: Bridgeport Police Department / Facebook

More than a year after Evelyn Rayo-Mairena, 24, was found shot on Black Rock Avenue in Bridgeport with her infant daughter left uninjured nearby, the man accused of killing her is back in Connecticut to face charges. Douglas Jose Centeno-Vargas, 31, was returned from Nicaragua to Bridgeport on Tuesday, capping a monthslong effort by investigators to bring him home.

Rayo-Mairena was found with a gunshot wound to her head on Black Rock Avenue on Oct. 21, 2025, around 9:30 p.m., according to The Hartford Courant. Her one-year-old daughter was found uninjured in a car seat with a bloodied blanket, the paper reported. Police allege Centeno-Vargas shot Rayo-Mairena inside his car, left the baby on a porch, and dragged the woman's body into the street, according to NBC Connecticut.

Investigators believe jealousy may have played a role in the killing, and Bridgeport Detective Jeffrey Holtz said investigators believed the killing was motivated by possessiveness, per the same NBC Connecticut report. A separate Spanish-language account from Infobae notes that the primary line of investigation points to a possible romantic motive, while cautioning that aspect remains part of the ongoing probe.

A Fast Flight Out of the Country

Police said Centeno-Vargas was driven to JFK International Airport immediately after the killing, then flew to El Salvador before continuing on to Nicaragua, per NBC Connecticut's reporting. Holtz said investigators were heartbroken when they discovered Centeno-Vargas had fled back to Nicaragua, his country of origin, shortly after the murder. The identity of the person who drove him to the airport remains under investigation, according to the Courant.

The U.S. Marshals Service launched an effort to locate Centeno-Vargas, and family members of Rayo-Mairena living in Nicaragua helped authorities track him down, according to detectives. Detectives also said the victim's family and the suspect's family lived in the same area of Nicaragua. Authorities say Centeno-Vargas was located in Nicaragua and his custody was secured over the summer with assistance from the U.S. Marshals Service and Interpol, as reported by ABC7 New York.

A Disputed Extradition Path

How exactly Centeno-Vargas ended up back in American custody involves a notable conflict in the record. Investigators quoted by NBC Connecticut said there is no extradition treaty between the United States and Nicaragua, and that the Nicaraguan government had offered to prosecute Centeno-Vargas on the murder charges in Nicaragua, an offer U.S. officials declined, according to Holtz. Investigators described the eventual return as the product of a lengthy negotiation.

That account differs from an archived report from the U.S. Department of State, which states that the United States and Nicaragua are parties to an extradition treaty signed in 1905 and ratified in 1907, while also noting that Nicaragua's constitution bars the extradition of its own citizens. The dossier of available reporting does not resolve this discrepancy between what investigators told reporters and what the archived State Department document describes.

What is established is the route Centeno-Vargas took once in American hands. He was flown to Houston, Texas, where he was charged as a fugitive from justice, and he was later transported from the Montgomery County Jail outside Houston to Bridgeport Police Headquarters by Bridgeport detectives, according to Yahoo News. He appeared before a Connecticut judge after authorities worked for months to return him to the state, ABC7 New York reported.

Charges and What Happens Next

Centeno-Vargas was charged with murder, risk of injury to a minor, and tampering with physical evidence, the Courant reported. Bridgeport police announced the arrest following his extradition and said he is accused of shooting and killing Rayo-Mairena, a 24-year-old South End mother, and placing her young daughter, who was in a baby carrier, on a front porch before fleeing. Investigators are still working to determine whether the person who drove Centeno-Vargas to the airport knew about the murder, and they are considering whether additional charges could be filed.

A relative of Rayo-Mairena's identified as Carolina said the arrest brought her family some measure of justice. She credited everyone involved with helping stop further violence and said the arrest proved that justice had been accomplished, according to reporting cited in the dossier of this case. As FOX61 first reported on the extradition, Bridgeport police have not indicated when Centeno-Vargas is expected back in court, and the outcome of any arraignment has not yet been reported.