
Cinderella is getting a serious reality check this December, and it is coming by way of a rogue fairy godmother and a stack of Britney Spears hits. The Actors Studio of New Jersey has announced the cast and creative team for Once Upon a One More Time, a jukebox musical reimagining fairy-tale princesses as it heads to the historic Dunellen Theatre at 458 North Avenue.
The musical follows fairytale princesses questioning traditional stories and expectations after Cinderella receives a copy of The Feminine Mystique, according to the seed facts behind this report, as detailed by TAPinto. As BroadwayWorld puts it, “Cinderella, Snow White, and the other fairytale princesses gather for their book club, when - oh, baby baby! - a rogue fairy godmother drops The Feminine Mystique into their corseted laps.” The story, according to the same listing, carries an original book by Jon Hartmere set to the songs of “the Princess of Pop herself, Britney Spears.”
A Pop Score Built for Empowerment
Per the production's own description, the musical explores independence, identity, empowerment, friendship and self-determination, set to a run of Britney Spears anthems including “...Baby One More Time,” “Oops!... I Did It Again,” “Lucky,” “Toxic” and “Stronger.” The Actors Studio of New Jersey frames the show in similarly playful terms on its website, saying “fairytales get a glitter-bomb makeover as Once Upon a One More Time spins classic princesses and pop anthems into a dazzling night of empowerment and fun.”
The TAPinto report lists performance dates of December 4 through 13, 2026, with shows on December 4 at 7:30 p.m., December 5 at 7:30 p.m., December 6 at 2:00 p.m., December 11 at 7:30 p.m., December 12 at 7:30 p.m., and December 13 at 2:00 p.m. A BroadwayWorld listing separately places the production's run at Dunellen Theatre beginning December 4, 2026.
Meet the Fairy-Tale Lineup
The cast includes Katie Claire McGrath as Cinderella, Aerika Gabbin as Snow White, and Andrew Tufano as Prince Charming, according to the production's announced casting. Kristin Wetherington plays the Stepmother, with Aaliyah Ellison and Melissa Calicchio rounding out the stepfamily as Betany and Belinda. Kimora Mitchell takes on Rapunzel, Karina Yakubisin plays Sleeping Beauty, and Devin Rain Leonard appears as Princess Pea.
Charley Rogers plays the Little Mermaid, while Bella Brodine takes on Belle and Makayla LaBode performs as Esmeralda, also serving as dance captain. Larry Brustofski narrates the story, and Kiley Rose Burke Perez plays the Fairy Godmother who sets the plot in motion. Rocky Lopez appears as the Little Girl, Mark Edelstein as Clumsy, and Jason Tobias as Prince Erudite, with Anthony Yakobchuk, Brendan Maly and Zay Tucker rounding out the ensemble of princes.
The Creative Team Behind the Curtain
Michael Restaino directs the production, with Adriana Negron choreographing. James Russo serves as associate director and lighting designer, and Daniela Jimenez Ochoa is music director. Behind the scenes, Dan F. Sims serves as production manager and Joey Palazzo as stage manager, while Chandy Bennett designs costumes, Robert Delgado designs wigs, Chuck Lid designs sets and Scott Festa handles sound engineering.
This is not the first time Restaino and Negron have paired up at the Dunellen Theatre. The two also directed and choreographed, respectively, the company's No Place Like Home for the Holidays, which BroadwayWorld described as the Actors Studio's fourth production at the venue, following American Idiot, Welcome to the Heartbreak Hotel and Cruel Intentions: The 90's Musical.
A Residency Backed by State Arts Funding
Once Upon a One More Time arrives as part of the Actors Studio of New Jersey's ongoing residency at the Dunellen Theatre, a residency the company's website says is supported in part by the New Jersey Economic Development Authority's A.R.T. Phase II Grant Program, which aims to strengthen the state's arts and entertainment industry. The Actors Studio has said that program support has helped it expand production capabilities, invest in theatrical equipment and technical resources, and develop its professional producing theater company.
The size of that NJEDA grant has been reported two different ways: Insider NJ put the award at $382,896.88, while MyCentralJersey reported the figure as $382,896. Either way, the funding has helped cement the Actors Studio's presence at the North Avenue venue, where the company first announced its residency and a 2026 season of live, professional theater for the Dunellen community.









