New York City/ Crime & Emergencies

Brooklyn Reporter's Press Pass Fight Fails After Phone Use at Federal Trial

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Brooklyn Reporter's Press Pass Fight Fails After Phone Use at Federal Trial225 Cadman Plaza E — Reported Site of Trial Press-Pass Dispute
Google Street View

A federal judge has refused to order Brooklyn's federal courthouse to return press credentials to Inner City Press reporter Matthew Russell Lee, who lost access to two high-profile criminal trials after briefly using his phone inside a courtroom where electronics were banned. The ruling, issued Sunday in Manhattan, leaves Lee able to keep watching the proceedings and taking handwritten notes, but without the press pass he had used to cover the trials.

What Happened Inside the Courtroom

According to a federal court opinion detailed by courtlistener.com, Lee had held press passes to cover two separate cases at the courthouse at 225 Cadman Plaza East: United States v. Clase de la Cruz, a baseball bribery case, and United States v. Huawei. On November 4, while covering the Clase trial, Lee “briefly used his [cell] phone in the courtroom,” the opinion states, inside a room where a posted sign warned that “the use of phones and electronics is prohibited in the courtroom.”

Courthouse staff moved to revoke his credentials for both trials as a result, according to the court record. The office of District Executive Eugene Corcoran, which issues the court's press passes, determined that Lee's press credentials for the Clase and Huawei trials would be revoked following the incident.

Lee Sues, Judge Declines Emergency Order

Lee filed a lawsuit against Corcoran and other defendants along with an emergency motion for a temporary restraining order on November 11, seeking the immediate return of his credentials. Per the court record, the case landed before Judge J. Paul Oetken, who denied the emergency request on November 15 in Manhattan.

Oetken found that Lee had not shown his constitutional rights were likely violated, concluding he had not demonstrated a likelihood of success on his First Amendment retaliation claim at this stage of the case. The ruling addressed whether Lee had shown a likelihood of success at this stage.

Lee Can Still Attend, Just Not With His Devices

The ruling does not shut Lee out of the courtroom entirely. He remains free to sit in on both trials and take notes by hand, even without the press credentials that had previously given him broader access. As reported by Bushwick Daily, government lawyers addressed the courthouse's device rule in a letter on November 18.

That question could matter for Lee specifically, given his dual status as both a reporter and a licensed Eastern District attorney. The court's denial of the temporary restraining order addressed only the emergency request for immediate relief, and the underlying lawsuit against Corcoran and the other named defendants remains pending.