
A fight inside an Ocean Hill high school turned violent Thursday morning when a 16-year-old girl slashed a 15-year-old classmate across the forehead with a scalpel. A teacher was slashed while trying to break it up, according to police. The brawl unfolded just before 10:15 a.m. at I.S. 55/Brooklyn Collegiate: A College Board School at 2021 Bergen St., leaving two people hurt.
According to abc7NY, the incident happened at about 10:12 a.m. inside the school. A 61-year-old school employee was slashed in the left hand while attempting to separate the two students, the outlet reported, while a third girl nearby was not injured but had her jacket ripped by the scalpel. News 12 Brooklyn reported that the man slashed in the hand was a teacher who had attempted to break up the fight, and that paramedics took both the student and the teacher to Maimonides Hospital, where the NYPD listed them in stable condition.
Scanners in Place but Scalpel Still Got Through
Officials said the school uses scanners, but scalpels frequently are not detected by the scanning machines, per the same abc7NY report. Scalpels made mostly of plastic can evade metal-detector screening.
The scanning shortfall is not new. A school safety agents' union leader told CBS News New York that scalpels made mostly of plastic have slipped past detection equipment, and the NYPD told that outlet it recovered 233 scalpels on school property between July 1, 2025, and Jan. 14, 2026. The NYPD also said 177 active scanners were deployed across the school system, representing just a fraction of the city's schools, according to that report.
Metal-Detector Screening Across the City
Metal-detector screening is used at some New York City schools. ProPublica and WNYC counted students at more than 236 city schools required to pass through metal detectors, affecting more than 100,000 middle and high school students on a typical day. A NYPD document obtained by ProPublica found just 126 possible weapons — including 73 knives and 21 boxcutters — turned up across roughly three million scans conducted over the first two months of that school year.
The equipment itself has had reliability problems. Chalkbeat reported that as of April 2025, the city's pop-up school metal-detector program had ground to a halt because its mobile unit had no working X-ray machines, prompting an emergency contract to buy 15 new scanners for nearly $385,000 that had not yet been delivered. That same report found 86 city public school campuses had permanent metal detectors and X-ray machines installed.
A Familiar Pattern From the Bronx
Brooklyn's scalpel attack follows a similar episode almost exactly one year earlier in the Bronx. A 17-year-old boy was slashed in the head and neck with a scalpel during a fight at Fordham Leadership Academy on Nov. 21, 2025, according to the New York Daily News. EMS rushed that student to St. Barnabas Hospital, where he was listed in stable condition, and police took two of his classmates into custody, though no arrests had been made at the time that story published. The Daily News also noted that in February, a 15-year-old student at the same Bronx campus had been slashed in the face by a classmate while walking home from school.
Investigation Continues
Police took the 16-year-old girl suspected of wielding the scalpel into custody, and charges were pending as of Thursday afternoon, per abc7NY's reporting. No official charges had been released as of publication. News 12 Brooklyn said it was awaiting a response from the Department of Education.









