
Cacique Restaurant has closed after 22 years at 26 N. Market St. in downtown Frederick. The Frederick News-Post reported that the Frederick County Sheriff's Office evicted the business last Wednesday; the restaurant did not formally announce its closure, and its Facebook page lists it as permanently closed. Court documents cited in the report showed Cacique owed more than $30,000 in rent and utilities.
The eviction followed an earlier dispute over the lease. In its reporting, The Frederick News-Post said building owner Paul DiFrancesco tried to end the tenancy in 2023, citing two late rent payments and alleging that Cacique would not leave after the lease expired.
The earlier case reached Maryland's highest court. In July 2025, the Maryland Supreme Court ruled that DiFrancesco could not use that specific type of eviction. The opinion, authored by Justice Brynja M. Booth, distinguished between an expired lease and a terminated lease for purposes of the eviction law. Cacique continued operating downtown after the ruling.
Unpaid Rent Piled Up After the Ruling
A separate repossession filing followed. According to the News-Post's account of court documents, Cacique stopped paying rent for August, September and October and stopped communicating with DiFrancesco. He later sought repossession of the property.
DiFrancesco told the News-Post he could not afford to continue the arrangement.
The News-Post reported it was unable to reach Cacique's owners, a marketing representative, or the restaurant's former attorney for comment on the closure.
Downtown Partnership Sees an Opening
Brenna O’Malley, business development manager for the Downtown Frederick Partnership, described Cacique as an institution downtown and said she hoped its closure would give another small business an opportunity to come downtown and open.
Cacique's closure follows word that another downtown Frederick restaurant, 7th Sister, plans to close in early December, according to a post on the restaurant's Facebook page reported by The Frederick News-Post. Together, the two closures mark a rough stretch for the city's downtown restaurant scene as the holiday season approaches.
Downtown Business Conditions
According to the Downtown Frederick Partnership’s 2024 Business Performance Survey, 47% of 93 responding businesses said profits were “much better” or “slightly better” in 2024, up from 42% in 2023. Respondents also identified rising costs, foot traffic and employee retention as leading challenges for 2025. The survey covered downtown businesses generally, so these findings offer context on business sentiment but do not provide a restaurant-specific explanation for Cacique’s closure or trends in food-service establishment counts and employment.









