Sacramento/ Politics & Govt

California Fines Anthem Blue Cross $1.1M After 10-Year-Old's Mental Health Care Stalled

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
California Fines Anthem Blue Cross $1.1M After 10-Year-Old's Mental Health Care Stalled980 9th St #500 — State Regulator That Imposed Fine
Google Street View

A California mother spent three months fighting her own health insurer to get mental health treatment for her 10-year-old child, only for the child's condition to worsen while she waited. Now the state has stepped in, fining Blue Cross of California $1.1 million over the delay.

The California Department of Managed Health Care levied the penalty after finding that Blue Cross of California failed to obtain behavioral health care for the child, according to Action News Now. The child had behavioral health conditions, and the outlet reports that Anthem Blue Cross failed to properly acknowledge the family's complaints and failed to arrange out-of-network treatment when an in-network provider wasn't available.

According to the report, the mother contacted Anthem Blue Cross repeatedly over the three-month span seeking help, while the insurer failed to arrange treatment and the child's condition worsened. It wasn't until she called the DMHC Help Center that Anthem authorized out-of-network behavioral health treatment. Even then, the insurer mishandled claims repeatedly after approving that out-of-network care, the report states.

Regulators Say the Case Reflects a Broader Access Right

DMHC official Dan Southard said health plans must arrange timely out-of-network care when in-network behavioral health providers aren't available, per the same account. He added that parents should not have to battle their health plan for months to secure critical behavioral health treatment for their child. Health plan members have a right to timely and geographically accessible behavioral health services, and plans must arrange and cover out-of-network services at no additional cost when in-network options are unavailable, the report notes.

As part of the enforcement action, Anthem Blue Cross has committed to reprocessing any improperly processed claims tied to the case. The insurer also said it will review its policies and procedures for coverage and timely access to medically necessary behavioral health services, as well as the member complaints identified in the matter, the outlet reports.

A Pattern of Fines Against the Insurer

This is far from the first time the DMHC has penalized Anthem Blue Cross over how it handles member complaints. The agency separately found that Anthem had failed to appropriately identify, timely process, or resolve member grievances for more than 15 years, which contributed to a $15 million fine against the insurer, Action News Now reported in earlier coverage.

That same report detailed a string of prior penalties: a $3.5 million fine in December 2024 for sending members late grievance acknowledgment letters, and a $500,000 fine in November 2024 after a member's cancer treatment was delayed due to grievance-handling failures. The DMHC had also fined Anthem $2.8 million in June 2019 and $2.5 million in November 2009 for similar deficiencies, according to the outlet.

A DMHC behavioral health investigations summary separately reported persistent gaps in network adequacy for behavioral health services, including specialty care, in certain geographic areas, according to a DMHC report.

What the Law Requires

Under state law, timely-access standards for mental health and substance-use care are treated as minimum requirements, not ceilings. Bill text from California Legislative Information for SB 221 states that a treating provider's clinical judgment continues to play the primary role in decisions about the speed and frequency of medically necessary care.

Members who run into similar problems with their health plan can file a complaint with the DMHC Help Center or apply for an independent medical review through the same office. The DMHC Help Center can be reached online at www.dmhc.ca.gov or by phone at 1-888-466-2219.