Philadelphia/ Politics & Govt

Camden Judge Holds County GOP Liable for 2023 Moriarty Mailer

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Camden Judge Holds County GOP Liable for 2023 Moriarty MailerSource: Yassie / Wikimedia Commons

A Superior Court judge has found the Camden County Republican organization liable for defamation and false light over a 2023 campaign mailer that called State Sen. Paul Moriarty a drunk driver. The October 30 order decides liability against the county party and stops there.

Damages are still unwritten, and the claims against other defendants are still open. New Jersey Globe reported Monday that Judge Michael J. Kassel granted the Washington Township Democrat partial summary judgment. Moriarty wants compensatory and punitive damages, legal fees and court costs. No monetary judgment has been entered.

The Piece Voters Received

Shortly before the November 2023 legislative elections, the mailer went to voters in the 3rd and 4th districts. Photographs of Moriarty and John Burzichelli sat under a headline asking what a "porno producer" and a "drunk driver" had in common. The county GOP paid for it.

Then-chairman Thomas Crone authorized the advertisement on the organization's behalf. He later acknowledged under oath that he knew the criminal record did not match the label. "I was aware that then Assemblyman Paul Moriarty had been accused of drunk driving in the past but that he was never convicted of such an offense," he said.

Moriarty's lawyers argued that line was a knowingly false statement of fact, not ordinary political criticism. Public officials have to prove a false statement was made knowingly or with reckless disregard for the truth, the actual-malice standard. Kassel found the county GOP liable on both defamation and false light as a matter of law, without a jury trial on those claims.

What the Order Leaves Open

The order applies only to the Camden County GOP. It does not impose personal liability on Crone, and it does not address the claims against him or against unidentified individuals and companies named in the amended complaint. It also does not explain how Kassel reached the decision, or whether Crone's actions, an organizational authorization or some other evidence supplied the basis.

That is a liability finding with no price tag. Moriarty filed the lawsuit in July 2024, naming the county GOP and Crone. What he is still seeking is money: compensatory damages, punitive damages, fees and costs. The court has awarded none of it.

A Dismissed 2012 Case

The mailer's accusation reached back to a 2012 arrest. Charges were later dismissed after evidence showed the arresting Washington Township police officer had falsified his report. More than a decade on, the piece treated that dismissed case as a present identity.

The criminal case and this political lawsuit are not the only court fights tied to that arrest. In a separate federal suit, a judge dismissed Moriarty's claims that the Washington Township Police Department failed to adequately train and supervise employees, WHYY reported. That dismissal does not decide what a campaign committee could print after the charges were already gone.

Who Authorized It

Richard Ambrosino told a different internal story. He maintained that Crone acted independently, consulted no one in the county GOP and bypassed the executive committee, which ordinarily reviewed controversial campaign literature. He said he knew nothing about the advertisement until after it was mailed, and that the publication was not made with the organization's knowledge and intent.

He also acknowledged paying the printer's invoice. He said another GOP leader directed production, and that Crone and that leader refused Moriarty's retraction demand. He alleged Crone had been promised the executive director job in the 4th Legislative District office if Republican candidates won, and that Crone allowed the mailer to be produced hoping to land that position.

In December 2023, John Zohlman demanded a written retraction sent to the same voters who received the original piece. Crone declined to issue a retraction or an apology. The judge has now found the organization liable anyway. The order does not say whether Crone's sworn authorization, Ambrosino's account of a bypassed committee, or something else carried the decision.

Cash on Hand, and a Smaller Bill

Crone has since lost the county chairmanship to Kimberly Stuart. As of an October 12, 2026 filing, Camden County Republicans reported $29,112 in campaign funds. The Globe described the organization as facing potentially significant financial liability from claims that still have no dollar figure. In 2026, county Republicans were also unable to field a full slate of candidates.

Separately in the mailer lawsuit, Superior Court Judge Steven Polansky ordered Crone to pay $934 in attorney fees for failing to comply with a subpoena and directed him to appear for a deposition, New Jersey Globe reported. Polansky warned that a failure to appear could bring discipline, including incarceration for willful noncompliance.

The $934 is a compliance bill, not a defamation award. Voters in two South Jersey districts got the headline in 2023. The court has said the organization that paid for it is liable. It has not said for how much, or what happens to the claims the October 30 order left untouched.