Philadelphia/ Politics & Govt

Camden Officials Demand Gov. Sherrill Remove Superintendent Llano Over School Shakeups

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Camden Officials Demand Gov. Sherrill Remove Superintendent Llano Over School ShakeupsCamden City School District — District At Center Of Shakeups
Google Street View

Camden Mayor Victor Carstarphen and a group of city officials are calling on Gov. Mikie Sherrill to remove state-appointed Schools Superintendent Alfonso Q. Llano Jr., saying his decisions over the past several months have eroded confidence in his ability to lead the district. The demand comes less than a year into Llano's tenure, which began with promise as the district's first Hispanic superintendent.

According to a letter dated November 10 and reviewed by Inquirer.com, officials sent their removal request to Sherrill and state Education Commissioner Lily Laux, citing serious concerns about Llano's leadership and the decisions he has made. The letter was signed by City Council President Angel Fuentes, Vice President Arthur Barclay, and former Mayor Dana L. Redd, and it was also signed by state Sen. Nilsa Cruz-Perez and Assemblymen William Spearman and William Moen. It was written on letterhead bearing city and Camden Education Fund logos, whose president is Gianna Campbell.

Officials criticized Llano for making consequential decisions with limited stakeholder engagement and insufficient planning, the letter states. Among the grievances cited: the district changed school start times with little notice to families, according to the letter. Llano also ended the longstanding uniform requirement at Camden high schools, replacing it with a dress code policy, and he attempted to consolidate the district's four magnet schools, a plan that faced pushback and protests.

The One Camden Flashpoint

Central to the dispute is Llano's move to pull district schools out of One Camden, the city's enrollment system. The letter says Llano notified One Camden Inc. that district schools planned to withdraw, after he issued a notice of termination to the organization on October 30. One Camden is an enrollment system for Camden schools.

Reaction to the termination notice has split sharply among local voices named in the dispute. Tameeka Mason called Llano's termination notice a misinformed policy decision and cited possible legal ramifications of terminating One Camden, while Vida Neil praised Llano's move to cut ties with the system. Neil believes One Camden is devouring the traditional school system and said Llano is not giving away more students, adding that efforts are underway to bring Camden children back. Critics more broadly have said the enrollment system has undermined traditional public schools, arguing that traditional Camden schools have lost students to charter and renaissance schools, taking funding with them. Jose E. Delgado, for his part, said simply to follow the money.

Enrollment Declines and Rising Charter Costs

The fight over One Camden is unfolding against a backdrop of a shrinking traditional public-school system. Traditional public-school enrollment fell from 11,660 students in 2013-14 to about 5,300 currently, a decline of nearly 50 percent, according to the letter's figures cited in the same Inquirer.com report. Separately, WHYY reported that district enrollment fell from 11,660 students in 2013-14 to 5,904 in 2023-24, also a nearly 50 percent drop, while the district announced cuts in response to a $91 million budget gap tied to declining enrollment and rising charter and renaissance school costs.

The two outlets differ slightly on how much the district has paid charter and renaissance schools over that period. Inquirer.com reported that district payments to those schools increased from $54.9 million to $198 million during the same period, while WHYY put the figure at $198.6 million. Either way, the trend has become a central argument for critics who say the enrollment pipeline has starved traditional schools of both students and funding.

A Superintendent Already Under Fire

Llano did not respond to a request for comment Monday, per the same Inquirer.com account. A spokesperson for the superintendent, Sheena Yera, said Llano remains focused on improving student outcomes, strengthening accountability, and prioritizing Camden students and families, and that he respects elected officials' and community stakeholders' right to express their views.

Llano was appointed superintendent by the state in January and started the job on March 1, succeeding Katrina T. McCombs after her contract was not renewed. He was selected to lead Camden schools. He has a three-year contract and earns $260,000 annually.

The push to oust Llano echoes an earlier chapter in Camden's superintendent turnover. Before Llano was selected, a search for McCombs's successor was underway; McCombs had led Camden schools beginning in 2018, according to a separate WHYY report. Whether the current push against Llano will lead to any formal action from the governor's office remains unclear.