
A 41-year-old Natural Bridge man is dead after a confrontation with New York State Police in Carthage last week, and the state's police oversight office has now formally opened an investigation into how he died. Zachary J. Strough was killed following a Nov. 11 encounter in the Jefferson County village, according to officials, after investigators tried to take him into custody on an outstanding warrant.
The New York Attorney General's Office of Special Investigation announced in a Nov. 16 news release that it had opened a case into Strough's death, as reported by FingerLakes1. The Attorney General's office, which oversees the unit, said in its own release that OSI had opened an investigation into the death of Zachary J. Strough following his Nov. 11 encounter with members of the New York State Police.
According to Flack Broadcasting, Strough had missed a court date and was wanted on a Lewis County bench warrant tied to a felony rape charge. State Police, assisted by the State Police Violent Gang and Narcotics Enforcement Team, sought to arrest him, and authorities attempted to intercept him on Nov. 11.
What Happened on West Street
The encounter took place at approximately 1:51 p.m. in Carthage, per the same account from FingerLakes1. Strough was reportedly a passenger in a pickup truck when an investigator approached the vehicle's passenger side after it stopped on West Street.
Police say Strough pointed a handgun at the investigator and did not comply with commands to disarm. A State Police member then fired a service weapon, striking Strough. Officers rendered aid, and Strough was taken to Carthage Area Hospital, where he later died. No State Police personnel were injured in the encounter.
An Account Still Described as Preliminary
The Attorney General's Office has said the facts of the incident are preliminary and subject to change as the investigation continues. That qualifier applies to the entire sequence of events as described so far, including the claim that Strough pointed a weapon at the investigator.
Under New York law, the Office of Special Investigation is required to review any incident in which a law enforcement officer may have caused a person's death through an act or omission. That review applies whether the officer was on or off duty, whether the person who died was armed or unarmed, and regardless of whether that person was in custody or incarcerated at the time. If the office's assessment indicates an officer may have caused the death, it proceeds to a full investigation, as outlined in the relevant section of New York State law.
No findings have been released, and the identity of the officer who fired has not been made public. It remains unclear what the investigation will ultimately determine or whether any further action will follow.









