
Eleven activists known as the CWRU 11 say all 33 felony charges connected to a November 2024 campus vandalism incident at Case Western Reserve University have been dismissed and cleared from their records. The group, which includes six current and former CWRU students, one Cleveland Institute of Art student, two Cleveland State University students and two community members, had spent nearly two years moving through a pretrial diversion process tied to roughly $400,000 in alleged property damage.
The case traces back to November 8, 2024, when protesters hung posters, left red handprints and painted messages around Adelbert Hall, along the Binary Walkway and outside the Mandel School of Applied Social Sciences, demonstrating against universities' alleged complicity in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. CWRU President Eric Kaler said at the time that individuals had vandalized campus buildings, structures and artwork with paint and glued posters, some of which the university considered to contain antisemitic language or symbols, according to The Observer. The university condemned the actions, launched an investigation, and said anyone found responsible would face both university conduct proceedings and criminal charges.
Four activists were taken to Cuyahoga County jail on vandalism charges in the aftermath, and a grand jury later indicted all 11 on counts tied to vandalism, breaking and entering, and possessing criminal tools. As Ideastream reported on February 20, 2025, the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office alleged that the group was responsible for $400,000 worth of damage, with each defendant facing one count of vandalism, a third-degree felony, one count of possessing criminal tools and one count of breaking and entering. A Cleveland State University student connected to the case also faced separate harassment charges for spam-calling a CWRU associate dean, per The Observer.
Diversion Deal Replaces Trial
Rather than go to trial, the defendants entered a pretrial diversion program that would drop the charges if they followed prosecutors' conditions, which included random drug tests, travel restrictions, restitution payments and staying out of further trouble. Defendants who refused the terms faced the possibility of prison time or felony records, according to The Observer's reporting. Accounts of exactly how many entered diversion differ: Ideastream reported in October that all 11 defendants had entered the program, while The Observer reported that ten of the 11 entered pretrial diversion and said it could not independently confirm that all 11 were eligible.
Ten of the activists ultimately signed the restitution agreement together under joint and several liability, meaning the full amount was owed regardless of how it was divided among them, The Observer reported. The eleventh activist reached a separate court agreement, pleading guilty to reduced charges, with a judge assigning her a $40,000 restitution share as part of her probation. Ideastream reported that eleven people, including six current and former students, agreed to pay $400,000 in restitution to avoid trial, and that the prosecutor's office said the majority of that amount was paid up front.
Damage Estimate Disputed
CWRU and prosecutors assessed property damage at $400,000 and the university requested full restitution within one year as a condition of resolving the charges, The Observer reported. But students and supporters have pushed back on that figure. Axios reported that CWRU has not provided a breakdown for those costs, leaving the basis for the $400,000 estimate unresolved. The Observer also reported that students accepted plea deals that would prevent further scrutiny of the restitution amount.
Separately from the criminal case, six convicted CWRU students faced internal university disciplinary actions, with criminal charges against them placed on hold pending completion of the diversion program, per The Observer. Three fourth-year students were barred from taking classes and had their diplomas withheld; the university offered to resolve those holds if the students identified others involved in the event, which the three refused to do, The Observer reported. Non-CWRU members of the group also received notices barring them from campus grounds.
Activists Renew Divestment Push
The Observer reported that the dismissal of the indictments marked completion of the diversion agreement with the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office, with ten program participants fulfilling all stipulations and raising funds to pay the university in full. Following the dismissal, activists renewed their demands for CWRU to divest from Israel and urged students to continue protesting as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict continues in the West Bank, according to The Observer.
Benjamin Mullin-Vanneste criticized the university's legal response as an effort to stifle dissent and silence the Palestine movement, The Observer reported. Raïssa Rih-Reh said universities should foster critical thought and train changemakers but had strayed from that mission, per the same account. The Cleveland Palestine Advocacy Community, which provided comments to The Observer about the felony dismissals, said it welcomed the dismissal of all 33 charges and argued that CWRU students continue to support Palestine and Palestinian human rights while the administration prioritizes student repression, support for genocide and appeasing donors. The group also said CWRU continues to receive significant amounts of money from Israel supporters, and noted it had supported a November 2024 campus protest calling on the administration to drop the charges.
Part of a Wider Pattern
The CWRU case fits into a broader national pattern of prosecutions tied to the 2024 pro-Palestinian protest movement, during which media tallies counted more than 3,000 arrests nationwide, according to Al-Monitor, citing Reuters. At Stanford, charges against five current and former students were set to be dismissed if they completed 100 hours of community service each and paid about $52,000 combined in restitution, NBC News reported, after a judge had declared a mistrial in that case when jurors could not reach a verdict.
At CWRU, the roots of the case stretch back to spring 2024 demonstrations, when an encampment and marches lasting two weeks led to two dozen students being detained by police but not arrested, according to Ideastream's reporting. The November 2024 vandalism incident followed those earlier protests, eventually leading to the indictments, the diversion program, and now the dismissals the CWRU 11 are publicizing.









