New York City/ Real Estate & Development

Catsimatidis Files 99-Unit Tower for Chelsea, Hits Exactly the Magic Unit Count

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Catsimatidis Files 99-Unit Tower for Chelsea, Hits Exactly the Magic Unit Count253 W. 24th St. — Approximate Site of Proposed Tower
Google Street View

Red Apple Group has filed plans for a 15-story residential building with 99 units, including 17 affordable units if the project is approved, at 253 West 24th Street in Manhattan’s Chelsea neighborhood. The filing calls for five to seven apartments on each of the first through 15th floors, packing the Chelsea block with a density that’s becoming oddly common across the five boroughs this year.

The plans, filed with New York City’s Department of Buildings and detailed by Commercial Observer in reporting attributed to a Thursday filing, list Chris Fogarty of Fogarty Finger as the project’s registered architect. According to the same report, citing PincusCo, residents would have access to a rooftop terrace, a lounge, coworking spaces, a children’s playroom, bike storage and a gym. John Catsimatidis, who owns Red Apple Group, did not immediately respond to Commercial Observer’s request for comment, and neither did Fogarty.

Catsimatidis purchased the 59,250-square-foot building at 253 West 24th Street for $22.5 million, and the site sits adjacent to Red Apple’s development project at 280 Eighth Avenue. The Real Deal reported that Catsimatidis closed on the property in 2024 for $22.5 million only after securing sign-off from the New York State Attorney General and the building’s longtime owner, Jeanne D’Arc Residence. At the time of that deal, Catsimatidis told the outlet his architects were still drawing up plans and that nothing had yet been filed with the city.

A Tangled History Next Door

Whether the new 253 West 24th Street filing connects to Red Apple’s adjacent 280 Eighth Avenue project is unclear, per Commercial Observer’s reporting. The history of that neighboring site has shifted in the telling: a 2022 Real Deal report described a 76,000-square-foot mixed-use project at 280 Eighth Avenue with 64 residential units, community space and ground-floor retail, designed by Hill West as a 10-story, 113-foot-tall building. By 2024, however, The Real Deal described Red Apple as developing a 104-unit residential building at the same address, while a separate account attributed to New York YIMBY put the project at 13 stories and 104 rental units. The dossier of reporting does not explain whether the plans changed between those accounts.

Community Board 4’s Housing Committee has already weighed in on the 253 West 24th Street proposal, voting to approve a presentation for the 99-unit project subject to conditions, according to Citizen Portal. The committee’s conditions called for free access to open outdoor space, a sliding-scale amenity fee by income band if any fee is charged at all, and a more equitable distribution of the building’s 40% AMI units across floors. The report describes a committee-level presentation vote, not a final sign-off on the project.

The 99-Unit Threshold

The project’s 99-unit count falls just below a notable threshold. Properties with 99 units or fewer can use New York’s 485-x tax abatement program without meeting the construction-wage requirements that apply to buildings with 100 or more units, Commercial Observer reported. Whether Red Apple is pursuing that incentive for 253 West 24th Street is unclear, the outlet noted, and the filing alone doesn’t establish the project’s eligibility or intent. The 485-x program itself implements the Affordable Neighborhoods for New Yorkers Tax Incentive Benefits Program under state law, with rules adopted by HPD under RPTL Section 485-x.

Red Apple is far from alone in landing on that number. The Real Estate Board of New York found 172 proposals for 99-unit buildings citywide between July 2024 and September 2026, with 123 appearing in DOB new-building filings and 49 in HPD’s prospective 485-x registration data, per the same Commercial Observer report on REBNY’s findings. That marks a dramatic shift from the 2008-through-2023 stretch, when only 13 buildings with exactly 99 proposed units were ever filed with the DOB.

A Citywide Pattern Takes Shape

The third quarter of 2026 alone saw 47 proposals for 99-unit buildings filed with the DOB, representing 4,653 apartments, or 31.6 percent of the 14,712 total proposed multifamily apartments filed that quarter. Those filings skewed heavily toward the outer boroughs: 18 in Brooklyn, 16 in the Bronx, 12 in Queens, just one in Manhattan, and none in Staten Island, according to REBNY’s data as reported by Commercial Observer. Basha Gerhards, REBNY’s executive vice president of public policy, is cited in that reporting as a voice on the trend.

The broader pipeline numbers underscore why developers are chasing every unit threshold available. REBNY’s own Q2 2026 pipeline report found 172 proposed multiple-dwelling filings that quarter totaling just 8,064 units, a 52 percent drop from the first quarter. That figure is less than half of the 17,500 units per quarter the city says it needs to reach its goal of 700,000 new homes over the next decade, according to the report.