Philadelphia/ Politics & Govt

Center City Residents Sue Philly, Say Bike Lane Ban Locks Out Disabled Riders

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Center City Residents Sue Philly, Say Bike Lane Ban Locks Out Disabled RidersW. 72nd St. — Approximate Site of Proposed Bike Lane
Google Street View

Two Philadelphia residents with mobility impairments are suing the city, arguing that its ban on cars stopping in bike lanes on Pine and Spruce streets violates federal disability law because it includes no exception for vehicles carrying people who can't easily get in and out of cars on their own.

The proposed class-action lawsuit comes from Susan Herskovits, a Spruce Street resident in her 80s, and Carl Roeder, a Pine Street resident in his 60s, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer. Both say they've had trouble getting in and out of rideshares safely since the prohibition took effect, and the complaint states plainly that the stopping ban contains no exception for a vehicle transporting people with mobility impairments. As CBS News Philadelphia reported, the lawsuit alleges the ban makes it impossible for people with some disabilities to get in and out of vehicles at all.

The lawsuit asks a judge to order the city to adopt a disability exception to the ban, along with a permit process and an accessibility evaluation of the safety upgrades planned for the two corridors. A separate report from Law360 identified the case as a putative class action filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.

A Ban Born From Tragedy

Philadelphia City Council passed the ordinance banning cars from stopping in the Spruce and Pine bike lanes, even briefly, in 2024. The citywide stopping ban and the broader push for safety upgrades followed the 2024 death of cyclist Barbara Friedes, a 30-year-old physician at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia who was killed when a drunk driver veered into the Spruce Street bike lane, the Inquirer's report noted.

The city's plan for the two corridors includes erecting concrete barriers and designating loading zones across from the bike lanes for residents to use. A city announcement from November 2024 described the underlying legislation, bill 240657, as the “Get Out the Bike Lane” law, making all curbside bike lanes “No Stopping Anytime” zones.

A Corridor Already Tangled in Litigation

This isn't the first lawsuit over how Philadelphia has handled Spruce and Pine. Friends of Pine and Spruce, a group representing some residents, sued the city in 2025 over its loading-zones plan, and a judge subsequently enjoined changes to the bike lanes. The city's appeal of that injunction remains pending in Commonwealth Court, per the same Inquirer account.

The dispute over these two corridors isn't new, either — skirmishes between residents and cyclists over the lanes date back to 2009, according to the newspaper's reporting. That long-running tension forms the backdrop against which the new ADA claims are now playing out, even as the earlier loading-zone fight is still working its way through the courts.

Not the Only City Facing This Fight

Philadelphia isn't alone in confronting this kind of challenge. In New York City, disabled residents along West 72nd Street sued this past summer to stop a proposed two-way protected bike lane, arguing it would restrict their safe access to vehicles and their ability to cross the street, according to West Side Rag. That suit likewise claimed violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act, along with New York State Human Rights Laws.

Whether Philadelphia's bike lane rules will be forced to change remains an open question. The case adds another layer to an already crowded legal fight over two of Center City's most contested streets, with residents, cyclists, and now disability advocates all pressing competing claims about how Spruce and Pine should work.