
Chesapeake's City Council will look noticeably different come January, with two incumbents and three challengers now confirmed as the winners of the city's five at-large seats. The finalized results, issued after provisional ballots were tabulated, show a fifth-place finish so close that fewer than 100 votes separated the winner from the runner-up.
According to The Virginian-Pilot, no candidate in the crowded 15-person field managed to clear 10% of the total vote. Janelle St. Louis led the pack with 9.8%, followed by Santiera Brown-Yearling at 9.5%, Amanda Newins at 9.4% and Daniel Rosinski at 9.2%. Jeff Jefferies rounded out the winning five with 9% of the vote, securing the final seat. The finalized results followed the tabulation of provisional ballots.
The outcome means St. Louis, Brown-Yearling and Rosinski — all backed by the Chesapeake Democratic Committee, per the same Virginian-Pilot report — will join Newins and Jefferies, both of whom ran for second terms, on the dais. Newins and Jefferies are the two incumbents retaining their seats, while St. Louis, Brown-Yearling and Rosinski are the three newcomers.
A Fifth-Seat Finish Decided by 91 Votes
The closeness of the race was evident even before certification. Earlier unofficial tallies reported by The Virginian-Pilot had shown roughly 415 votes separating Jennifer Naparela and Jefferies for the fifth seat, with provisional ballots still outstanding at the time. Once certified, that gap narrowed dramatically: Naparela finished just 91 votes short of claiming the fifth seat herself.
Naparela told the paper she will not pursue a recount. Virginia gives provisional ballots to voters whose registration or qualification is in question, and the state's Department of Elections requires the first local electoral board meeting reviewing those ballots to happen the day after Election Day, with the review required to conclude within seven days.
Candidates Who Fell Just Short
Behind the top five, the margins stayed tight. Todd Mayfield took 8.92% of the vote, Daniel Whitaker followed with 8.87%, and Eric Wray II came in at 8.19%. Whitaker, who did not secure reelection to a second term, said he does not intend to request a recount and wished the new council well. Mayfield could not be reached for comment, while Wray said he did not plan to pursue a recount, the paper reported.
Outgoing council members Jeff Bunn and Ella Ward will both depart their seats at the end of 2026, part of the broader turnover alongside Whitaker's loss. The city's official notice confirms the newly elected officials will begin their terms on January 1, 2027 — a timeline consistent with the city's handling of a prior election, when it similarly reported certified results for mayor, City Council and School Board races and set a January 1, 2025 start date for those winners.
Recount Window Still Technically Open
Several candidates in the race finished within the 1% threshold required to request a recount, according to the Daily Press. Under Virginia law, candidates may request a recount within 10 days following certification of the election results — a window that, per the Virginian-Pilot's reporting, runs to November 23, 2026. The Code of Virginia specifies that a recount petition must be filed within 10 days of certification, though the statute itself does not spell out a calendar date specific to this race. The Virginia Department of Elections must certify statewide results by December 7, 2026.
The same night's returns showed a similarly scattered field in Chesapeake's School Board race, where unofficial results had incumbents Kim Scott and Amanda Quillin leading with 10.7% and 10.6% of the vote, respectively, per the Virginian-Pilot's earlier report. With the council race now finalized and Naparela, Whitaker and Wray not planning to seek recounts, Chesapeake's new nine-person council lineup appears set heading into the new year, though Mayfield could not be reached for comment.









