
About 75% of everyone hired into the Cleveland Division of Fire between 2015 and 2024 has been a white man, according to figures presented at a recent city council hearing. Of the division's 736 uniformed firefighters, just 99 are Black and only 18 are women — numbers that prompted one council member to call the department's progress since a decades-long federal consent decree ended “woefully inadequate.”
The blunt assessment came from Councilmember Stephanie Howse-Jones during a Cleveland City Council Workforce, Education, Training and Youth Development Committee meeting on November 10, according to Signal Cleveland. Black firefighters make up about 13.5% of the division's uniformed ranks, the outlet reported, a figure that has shifted little in recent years. The Cleveland Division of Fire operated under a federal consent decree from 1977 to 2013 that aimed to increase minority representation through changes to recruitment and hiring procedures, and Howse-Jones said the department has done little since that decree ended to ensure continued racial diversity and the inclusion of women.
A Pipeline That Starts Wide and Narrows Fast
The hiring cycle that began in 2023 drew more than 1,000 applications, Signal Cleveland reported, with more than 500 applicants completing and passing the Civil Service Exam. Cleveland 19 previously reported that 1,047 people applied for the fire academy that year, including 250 Black applicants and 112 Hispanic applicants — numbers that outlet described as part of a persistent trend of low minority representation among applicants and academy graduates, according to Cleveland 19.
From there, the process narrows considerably. Applicant files are anonymized for name, race, education and gender, and candidates are ranked by test scores plus mandatory point bonuses tied to military service, Cleveland residency, CMSD credit and seniority, the same hearing coverage noted. A 17-member Applicant Review Committee then reviews the top 72 scoring files and recommends candidates to the division chief and director of public safety, who selected 40 people for the most recent class. The city ultimately hired 35 of them.
Questions About Oversight During the Consent-Decree Era
Howse-Jones asked whether that Applicant Review Committee existed while the federal consent decree was still in effect, requesting an inquiry into the committee's history. No one at the hearing was able to answer the question, the hearing coverage noted. Howse-Jones also said she wanted an entity beyond the division itself to support the review committee during the current hiring cycle, and she joined Councilmember Richard Starr in raising concerns that Cleveland Fire manages much of its hiring internally without independent oversight. Starr separately said Cleveland police had seen more improvement in diversity, and he said he expected more interest and competition for fire department roles from Cleveland residents going forward.
The Civil Service Commission outlines the process and exam requirements, while the Cleveland Division of Fire’s internal Applicant Review Committee makes hiring recommendations based on test scores and background-check information. LeeAnne Guzman serves as project director and Daryl Eatman as chief examiner. Applicants previously had to submit six or seven residency verification documents to qualify for resident priority consideration; that number has since been reduced, per the same hearing account. The National Testing Network approved Cleveland City Hall as a verified testing site for the Civil Service Exam, which is required of all firefighter recruits, and the city has used City Hall as a testing location to draw more Cleveland residents into the pipeline. A National Testing Network posting for the 2025 cycle showed the application window ran from March 17 through June 13, with applicants given until June 20 to take the FireTEAM exam or submit a qualifying score; approved applicants were to receive both a practice-test and an actual-test voucher by email, according to National Testing Network.
Recruiters Describe a Pipeline That Loses Candidates
Cleveland Fire recruiters Antoine Cruz and Lieutenant Jeremy Caldwell told the committee that recruiters offer study tools and exam support to applicants, though that preparation requires applicants' own time and travel. “With the list being so large, you lose contact with these candidates,” Cruz said, per the hearing coverage. Caldwell emphasized engagement with the Cleveland Metropolitan School District as a way to boost local recruitment. Acting Fire Chief Vince DiTeodoro, who has served in the interim role since August, said applicants speak with the department's applicant processing team, though the hearing coverage noted Cleveland Fire has no formal process for in-person or oral interviews.
Howse-Jones pointed to Toledo's fire department as a model worth examining, saying that city has achieved greater diversity in its department and suggesting Cleveland officials consult Toledo and its fire chief directly. She praised the user-friendly organization and transparency of Toledo's fire department website and suggested Toledo's in-person and oral interviews as a possible template for Cleveland. Toledo's own numbers back up the comparison: its 2021 recruiting class was 28% women and 56% people of color, and that diversity remained above 50% in the 2022 incoming group, according to Firehouse. Toledo had approved and funded a full-time fire recruitment team back in 2019, the trade publication reported.
Leadership Change Still Under Wraps
Mayor Justin Bibb has already selected a candidate for the next permanent fire chief but has not yet disclosed that selection publicly, and the candidate has not been notified, the hearing coverage noted. Director of Public Safety Dornat “Wayne” Drummond was named in connection with the search, and a city official identified as Cole confirmed at the hearing that the selected candidate had not yet been notified.
Councilmember Tanmay Shah asked the presenting officials to identify what support they would need from council, including any charter changes or budget allocations, to make progress on hiring diversity. Council is now asking Cleveland Fire to define concrete actions on the issue before the department returns with its budget requests in early 2027. Signal Cleveland's coverage of the hearing was documented by Hannah Morgan with Cleveland Documenters.
The gap in Cleveland Fire's ranks has shown up in multiple independent counts over the past two years. News 5 Cleveland previously found that 74% of the department's firefighters were white and only 13% were Black, while reporting that 25% of the city's paramedics and EMTs and 32% of its police force are Black, according to News 5 Cleveland. Cleveland 19 separately reported that Hispanics make up just under 8% of the department and Asians about 0.2%. Then-Fire Chief Anthony Luke discussed awareness and representation with that outlet.









