Cleveland/ Crime & Emergencies

Cleveland Officers Who Fired at Fleeing Woman's Car Face Revived Lawsuit

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Cleveland Officers Who Fired at Fleeing Woman's Car Face Revived LawsuitSource: Google Street View

A Cleveland mother's lawsuit against two police officers who opened fire on her daughter's moving car is back on after an Ohio appeals court reversed a lower court's dismissal of the case. Antwoina Carter, 26, was killed on March 17, 2024, when a gunman riding in a pursuing vehicle fired at least 20 shots into the back of her car as she drove near East 105th Street and Garfield Avenue. Officers Dylan O'Donnell and Amanda Rock also fired at Carter's car that night, though investigators later determined neither officer's bullets caused her death.

The 8th District Court of Appeals ruled that Latrice Carter's lawsuit against the two Cleveland officers can proceed, reversing a Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court decision that had thrown the case out, according to Cleveland.com. The case now returns to Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, where Judge Kelly Gallagher had previously granted the officers' request to dismiss it. Carter's lawsuit, filed in July 2025, alleges the officers acted recklessly and caused her emotional distress through negligence when they fired toward her daughter's vehicle, as detailed by News 5 Cleveland.

According to the lawsuit, Cleveland officers had been dispatched to the Garfield Avenue home of Latrice Carter's mother when gunfire erupted nearby while the officers were speaking with her. Antwoina Carter's vehicle then approached the officers while being fired upon from the pursuing car, and in their motion to dismiss the case, the city said O'Donnell and Rock believed the gunfire was coming from Carter's vehicle itself. The lawsuit claims Latrice Carter told the officers they were shooting at her daughter before her daughter's car crashed, and that she suffered severe trauma, emotional distress and post-traumatic stress disorder after watching officers fire at the vehicle.

What the Investigations Found

A forensic investigation confirmed that neither O'Donnell nor Rock fired the fatal shot, per the same account from News 5 Cleveland. But a separate internal investigation concluded the two officers violated the Cleveland Division of Police's use-of-deadly-force policy by firing their weapons at all. O'Donnell received a 15-day unpaid suspension, while Rock received a 10-day unpaid suspension, the station's report states.

A letter from Cleveland Public Safety Director Wayne Drummond acknowledged that officers faced a stressful, chaotic and dangerous situation and feared for their lives, but said the investigation concluded that the standard requiring officers to verify a visible and immediate threat before firing was ultimately not met. O'Donnell resigned from the Cleveland Division of Police in August 2025 and is now employed full-time as an officer with the Bentleyville Police Department, while Rock remains employed by Cleveland police.

The Legal Fight Over Immunity

The officers' attorneys had argued that political-subdivision employees generally have immunity from negligence claims under Ohio law, and asked Judge Gallagher to dismiss the case on those grounds. Ohio law does provide that government employees generally have immunity that can be lost through wanton or reckless conduct. In the appellate opinion, Judge Sean Gallagher wrote that Carter's complaint alleged reckless conduct sufficient to survive dismissal at this stage, adding that “this is not a case involving allegations of mere negligence.” Judges Lisa Forbes and Mary Boyle concurred in the decision.

The appeals court found that dismissing the case at that stage was premature, but the ruling does not determine whether O'Donnell or Rock actually acted recklessly — that question remains for the lower court to sort out now that the case has been sent back to Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court.

The Gunman's Sentence

Christopher Stinson, the gunman who authorities say killed Antwoina Carter, pleaded guilty on January 23, 2025, and was sentenced to 27 to 32.5 years in prison, according to the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office. Prosecutors said Stinson fired at least 20 shots at the rear of Carter's vehicle, striking her in the back, as she drove near her residence in the early morning hours.

Part of a Broader Pattern in Cleveland Courts

The ruling comes less than two weeks after the same appellate court allowed a separate lawsuit against the city of Cleveland to move forward. On Nov. 5, the 8th District Court of Appeals upheld a Cuyahoga County Common Pleas judge's decision letting Danielle Lewis pursue her own suit against the city over a 2024 crash involving a police cruiser, as reported by Cleveland.com.

The case also lands amid a broader rise in use-of-force incidents across the Cleveland Division of Police. The department recorded 334 use-of-force incidents in 2024, up from 283 in 2023 and a pandemic-era low of 195 in 2021, according to a report from Ideastream Public Media. Even so, the city's federal monitor found that force used in 97% of 272 reviewed cases — nearly all from 2024 — was necessary, proportional and reasonable.