Denver/ Crime & Emergencies

Colorado Court Upholds Vallecito Dad's Murder Conviction In Son's 2012 Death

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 15, 2026
Colorado Court Upholds Vallecito Dad's Murder Conviction In Son's 2012 DeathSource: General Services Administration / Wikimedia Commons

The Colorado Court of Appeals has upheld the murder conviction of Mark Redwine, the Vallecito man found guilty of killing his 13-year-old son Dylan during a court-ordered visit in November 2012. The appellate court rejected all six errors Redwine alleged occurred during his trial, leaving his 48-year prison sentence intact.

Appeals Court Rejects Every Challenge

Redwine appealed his conviction by alleging six separate errors with the judicial process, and the court rejected each one, according to the Durango Herald. The ruling, issued in People v. Redwine, formally affirmed the judgment against him, according to a case summary published by Colorado Lawyer. A jury convicted Redwine of second-degree murder and child abuse resulting in death, and the trial court sentenced him to 48 years in the custody of the Department of Corrections on October 8, 2021, according to the Colorado Court of Appeals opinion hosted by Justia.

Dylan went missing in November 2012 while on a court-ordered visit with his father in Vallecito, the same account notes. Partial remains were found on Middle Mountain Road in June 2013, and in November 2015 hikers found his skull about two miles from that first recovery site, per the Colorado Lawyer summary. Forensic anthropologists concluded the skull injuries were consistent with blunt-force trauma and knife wounds.

Venue, Jury Selection and Pretrial Publicity

Among Redwine's claims was that the trial court wrongly denied his motion to change venue given the extensive publicity surrounding Dylan's disappearance. The trial court found that media attention had declined by the time the case went to trial eight years after Dylan vanished, and it used a much larger jury pool than normal along with a highly detailed juror questionnaire as safeguards, the Durango Herald reported. The appellate court agreed the safeguards were sufficient, stating that pretrial publicity alone does not create a due-process right to change venue.

The disappearance had drawn sustained coverage, with the Herald itself having published roughly 150 articles about the case over the years. Redwine was not arrested and charged until July 2017, nearly five years after Dylan went missing, and a jury found him guilty in July 2021.

Disputed Testimony and a Threatening Log Incident

Redwine also challenged the admission of evidence tied to specific incidents of alleged misconduct. One involved photos Dylan discovered in 2011 showing his father eating feces from a diaper while wearing women's clothing; Redwine's son had asked a sibling for those photos in 2012 intending to confront him. After two women confronted Redwine on his property about the photo, he reportedly threatened them with a log, and the trial court admitted that incident as evidence of possible motive and lack of self-control.

The appellate court ruled the trial court properly admitted both the photos and the log incident. It did find one misstep: allowing testimony from Redwine's ex-wife, who said he once remarked that a remote camping spot would be a good place to get rid of a body, around 1991. Judges concluded that admitting her testimony was an abuse of discretion but deemed the error harmless to the overall verdict — the only mistake the court identified in the entire proceeding.

Cadaver Dog Evidence and Home Search Upheld

Redwine argued that expert testimony lacked a proper evidentiary foundation and that evidence stemmed from a warrantless cadaver-dog search of his home. A cadaver dog had alerted to scent in his living room, washing machine, pickup truck and clothes in August 2013. The Colorado Court of Appeals upheld admission of the dog handler's testimony after the trial court held a three-day reliability hearing, per Colorado Lawyer.

On the search itself, officers told Redwine in August 2013 that they intended to bring the scent dog onto his property, and he permitted them to proceed; he also agreed officers could enter his home through an open window as long as they avoided property damage. The trial court found he knew his rights when he consented, and the appellate panel agreed he validly consented to the search.

Judge's Conduct and Prosecutor's Closing Argument

Redwine further alleged that Judge Jeffrey Wilson showed pervasive bias that deprived him of a fair trial. The Court of Appeals found the record showed no overt hostility from Wilson, who was sometimes impatient but maintained courtroom order and kept evidence moving efficiently. He also argued the prosecutor's closing arguments amounted to misconduct by calling him a murderer and faulting him for going to trial, but the appellate court found the prosecutor used permissible rhetorical devices and committed no error. Redwine's final argument, that the cumulative weight of these alleged errors warranted reversal, was rejected along with the rest.

Prosecutors React to the Ruling

Sixth Judicial District Attorney Sean Murray said the appellate decision reflected the prosecution team's achievement in securing an accurate verdict while protecting the defendant's rights. Murray credited the work of Michael Dougherty, Christian Champagne, Fred Johnson, Karen Naber and the La Plata County Sheriff's Office, and said he hoped the outcome would bring closure to Dylan's family and community.

A separate appeal decided in April 2026 affirmed a $900 restitution order covering the cost of Dylan's burial plot, according to the Colorado Court of Appeals opinion hosted by Justia — a distinct ruling from this week's decision upholding the murder conviction itself.