
Alan Kennedy was a Colorado Army National Guard captain in May 2020 when he joined thousands of people marching through downtown Denver in the Black Lives Matter protests following George Floyd's murder. He went as a private citizen, off duty and out of uniform. More than six years later, the legal fight over what happened next is finally heading to trial.
According to 9News, U.S. District Judge William J. Martínez issued two rulings on November 4 allowing portions of Kennedy's lawsuit to proceed. The May 30, 2020 demonstration itself turned chaotic, with police and protesters clashing and Denver police officers deploying tear gas, per the same report. Kennedy, now a military attorney in the U.S. Army Reserve, says the issues at trial concern enduring constitutional questions about the rights of service members and all Americans.
An Op-Ed, Then an Investigation
Days after the protest, on June 4, 2020, Kennedy published an opinion piece in the Denver Post criticizing the Denver Police Department's use of force against demonstrators. The Colorado Army National Guard opened an investigation into both his protest participation and the op-ed that very same day, according to a court record reproduced by law.justia.com.
Kennedy says the Colorado National Guard investigated and reprimanded him and tried to end his military career over it, per 9News. On July 12, 2020, he received a Letter of Reprimand based in part on Department of Defense Instruction 1325.06, which prohibits military members from participating in certain demonstrations where violence is likely to result, the court filing shows. According to Kennedy's lawsuit, National Guard leadership determined that violence was likely at the protest — but Kennedy argues he had no reason to believe the demonstration would become violent, and 9News reports that an initial military investigation had concluded his participation was peaceful and protected by the First Amendment.
A Lawsuit, an Appeal, and a Promotion
Kennedy filed his federal lawsuit in March 2021, challenging the constitutionality of the military's protest restrictions and alleging retaliation. He also appealed several disciplinary actions against him, and those appeals eventually succeeded: an Army review board ordered the reprimand and associated disciplinary documents removed from his records, as KUNC reported at the time.
The court record shows Kennedy was promoted to major on June 14, 2022, and he later transferred to the U.S. Army Reserve, where he continues to serve as a military attorney. But clearing his record didn't end the case. As Military Times put it after the Army's reversal, his lawsuit against his former leaders continued in federal court. Kennedy argues that removing the records doesn't resolve the larger constitutional questions, and he contends the disciplinary actions affected his military career regardless.
Mixed Rulings Set Up a Trial
The case has had its share of setbacks. In August 2022, Judge Martínez dismissed Kennedy's second amended complaint without prejudice, according to the court record. Colorado National Guard officials were later dismissed from the suit following the corrective actions involving Kennedy's military records, and the remaining defendants now include the secretary of defense, the secretary of the army, and the chief of the National Guard Bureau in their official capacities, per 9News.
In the rulings issued November 4, Martínez upheld the military regulation against Kennedy's broader constitutional challenge, finding that the restriction itself is not unconstitutional on its face. But the judge also determined that factual disputes remain over whether the regulation was unconstitutionally applied to Kennedy specifically, and over whether military leadership retaliated against him for protected speech — meaning those claims will go before a jury.
Federal attorneys have defended the military's authority to restrict participation in demonstrations where violence is likely, citing safety and military readiness concerns, 9News reports. They have disputed Kennedy's allegations that his career setbacks resulted from unconstitutional retaliation. 9News says it reached out to the Colorado National Guard for comment on Kennedy's allegations, but the Guard had not provided a response as of Monday.
What Kennedy Is Fighting For
Kennedy said he was grateful his constitutional claim was allowed to go to trial, framing the fight as bigger than his own record. He said his military service includes fighting for fundamental rights, including free speech and protest, and argues the military unfairly punished him for exercising his constitutional rights.
No trial date has been set yet, according to 9News. For now, Kennedy's case stands as a test of how far the military's authority to limit off-duty political speech can reach — and whether a captain who marched through downtown Denver one spring evening in 2020 was protected by the Constitution or properly reined in by regulation.









