
A man who evaded police for more than a decade after a three-year-old boy died in his care was sentenced this week to three years in prison — the maximum allowed under his plea deal — leaving him with roughly 16 more months behind bars before his release. Roberto Avina-Casillas pleaded guilty to reckless homicide in the 2013 death of Alonzo Soeuk, the son of his live-in girlfriend, in Columbus.
Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Stephen McIntosh handed down the maximum 36-month sentence, according to WSYX. With 602 days of jail credit already applied, Avina-Casillas will be required to serve a little more than 16 months before he is eligible for release. Once out, he will be placed on post-release control and supervised by state corrections for up to two years, and he could be sent back to prison if he violates the terms of that supervision.
From Murder Charges to a Plea Deal
Avina-Casillas was originally indicted on murder and several other felonies in 2014, the year after Alonzo's death, the same report notes. As part of a later plea deal, those charges were resolved down to a single guilty plea to reckless homicide. Charging documents cited in the report state that Avina-Casillas squeezed the child so hard during an argument with the boy's mother that it caused him to hemorrhage internally.
Rather than face trial, Avina-Casillas disappeared, eluding authorities for more than a decade. During that time, he was featured on ABC 6's Wall of Justice, a recurring segment highlighting fugitives wanted by local law enforcement. He was finally captured in 2025, more than twelve years after the boy's death, bringing him back to Franklin County to answer for the case.
An Earlier Extradition From Mexico
The case had crossed international lines before. A separate report from ABC6OnYourSide detailed how Avina-Casillas had been extradited from Mexico to Franklin County to stand trial over the boy's 2013 death. A U.S. Department of Justice summary further states that Avina-Casillas, a Mexican citizen, was extradited from Mexico on April 4, 2025, to face trial in Franklin County on charges of murder, felonious assault and endangering children.
Grandmother Forgives, Relative Calls Sentence Too Light
Reactions to the sentence split sharply along emotional lines. Devear Jackson, Alonzo's grandmother, said she forgave Avina-Casillas despite everything she lost. “I forgive you, not that I choose to, because god will be pleased with me,” she said, according to the station's report. Jackson also said she missed the chance to do the simple things with her grandson that families take for granted.
Not everyone shared her outlook. Dustin Frank said Avina-Casillas deserved far more time than he received, calling the 36-month sentence ludicrous and arguing that “15 years behind bars is the least he deserves,” per the same account. Judge McIntosh himself acknowledged the gap between the law and the family's expectations, saying the sentence likely would not satisfy the family.
Alonzo Soeuk was three years old when he died in 2013. More than twelve years later, the case has finally reached a resolution in a Franklin County courtroom — though for relatives like Frank, the outcome still falls far short of what they believe justice should look like.









