
Students taking New York City's Specialized High School Admissions Test were sent home Saturday after a technical disruption stopped the digital exam. Some could not log on. Others had to stop midway.
A Department of Education letter put the number at about 2,500 and said testing was discontinued and students were dismissed. It promised a new date for students scheduled that day, with families to be notified by November 20. The exam determines admission to eight of the city's nine specialized high schools, which is why a failed login is not a routine delay. The New York Post reported the letter and the sites where the problems hit.
Dismissed Before the Clock Ran Out
The trouble was not confined to one building. The Post reported technical problems at multiple testing sites across the city, including Brooklyn Technical High School and Stuyvesant. Some students never got past the login. Others were already in the exam when they were told to stop.
In the Post's account, one parent said a son spent more than four hours at Brooklyn Tech. He tested for two hours, then was told to stop, and left stressed and exhausted. Two hours is a long time to be inside a high-stakes exam and still not be finished with it.
The 2026 admissions guide describes a different kind of endurance. Students take the test on a computer device provided at the site and select answers in an online form. All students must stay in the testing room for the entire standard administration, 180 minutes. Saturday ended before that sitting did.
Two Deadlines, One Missing Date
The letter's remedy is another sitting, not a patched Saturday. Students scheduled for the exam that day are to receive a new test date, and families are supposed to learn it by November 20. Students who completed the test but believe technical issues hurt their performance may request a retest. One path is for an exam the department discontinued. The other is for an exam a student finished and still does not trust.
The guide has not been rewritten to match the letter. It lists technical difficulties among the problems a student should bring to the proctor immediately. A request to look into a suspected testing irregularity must be submitted electronically or by certified mail no later than one week after the administration date. For Saturday's test, that is November 21. The makeup-date notice is due the day before. Families are being asked to watch two calendars that do not quite match.
The Vendor in the Internal Email
Pearson was awarded a contract in 2024 to administer a digital SHSAT. The exam went digital in 2025. In 2026 the department rolled out an adaptive version for the first time, with question difficulty changing based on a student's correct answers. The Post reported that an internal department email, first reported by Susan Edelman, attributed Saturday's failure to significant problems at Pearson.
City Councilmember Susan Zhuang criticized the department for shifting blame to Pearson and said accountability cannot be outsourced. Manhattan Institute fellow Danyela Egorov called for an independent investigation into the department over the testing failure. The department did not return the Post's request for comment.
The email gives the department a place to point. It does not tell a parent at Brooklyn Tech when the next attempt will be, or which part of the system failed. Zhuang's objection was that the contract did not move the exam out of the city's hands. The missing comment did not fill that in.
Last Year's Trouble Was a Clock
The digital debut in 2025 was a narrower failure. Chalkbeat reported that about 19,500 eighth graders took the exam at their middle schools, and that the day went smoothly for most of them. The documented problem was an extended-time timer: the clock showed three hours where six hours were due. A principal said the same issue occurred at more than 15 Manhattan middle schools. Officials said four students would take a makeup because of that extended-time glitch. That year's test was not computer-adaptive.
This year's version changes the path of the questions themselves. A correct answer can lead to a harder one, so two students in the same room are not necessarily working through the same sequence. For a student stopped after two hours, the unanswered portion is not a fixed stack of items waiting on a desk. On its SHSAT page, the department says the process for converting performance scores to final reported scores remains consistent with previous administrations. That is a statement about scoring, not about a session cut off by the software. Last year, officials were arranging makeups for four students. Saturday's letter is about roughly 2,500 who could not log on or had to stop.
Not This Test, Not This Vendor
New York had already seen a large computer-based testing failure in 2026, on a different exam. On April 29, students in grades three through eight, from Buffalo to New York City, encountered login errors during math or English language arts tests, The New York Times reported. It was the second consecutive year a technological issue disrupted the state's computer-based standardized exams. NWEA identified a server problem and repaired it before school started the next day. More than 1,600 students at Zeta Charter Schools in the city had to give up on their English language arts assessments.
None of that identifies the SHSAT fault. The state exams were NWEA's to fix, and the company repaired the server before the next school day. The specialized-school test is a separate contract, and the only cause named in the reporting is the department email's reference to significant problems at Pearson. The likeness is what the student experiences: an error message, a stopped session, and a morning that does not count.
Eric Nadelstern, a former deputy chancellor for the division of school support and instruction, said the department should consider moving the test earlier than Thanksgiving recess in future years. Parents and students demonstrated on Sept. 9, 2018, against plans to remove the SHSAT. Families sent home on Saturday are waiting on something more immediate: the new date the letter said they would have by November 20.









