
Joan Tarshis, who sued Bill Cosby in 2023 over allegations dating back more than five decades, is now asking a judge to stop the 89-year-old comedian from selling or transferring any real estate. Her attorney filed court documents arguing that Cosby has already shown he will not use proceeds from property sales to pay verdicts against him.
According to TMZ, Tarshis's attorney pointed to reports that the asking price on one of Cosby's New York City properties dropped from roughly $7 million to around $5 million, a decline of roughly $2 million. The filing also cited reporting that Cosby has failed to pay any of the $59.25 million judgment awarded to fellow accuser Donna Motsinger in California. Tarshis's legal team argued that any proceeds from a property sale would not necessarily benefit Cosby's accusers.
Tarshis's Underlying Allegations
Tarshis's 2023 lawsuit alleges that Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted her on two separate occasions in the early 1970s. In one instance, she alleged, Cosby gave her a drink at a music festival that caused her to lose consciousness, and she later awoke naked beside him believing she had been sexually assaulted. In the other, she alleged that he attempted to remove her clothing after she became disoriented and then overpowered her and forced her to perform oral sex. These remain allegations in a civil case, not an adjudicated finding.
The $59.25 Million Verdict Against Cosby
The reference point driving Tarshis's filing is the outcome of a separate case brought by Donna Motsinger. A Los Angeles jury found Cosby liable in March for drugging and sexually assaulting Motsinger in 1972, according to Complex. Motsinger had alleged that Cosby invited her to a comedy performance, gave her wine and a pill she believed was aspirin, and assaulted her after she lost consciousness. Jurors awarded her $19.25 million in compensatory damages and $40 million in punitive damages, for a total of $59.25 million.
Motsinger described the verdict as long-overdue accountability, saying the jury saw the truth and held Cosby accountable, per the same account. In May, Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Bradley S. Phillips denied Cosby's request for a new trial, finding no irregularity prevented a fair proceeding and concluding that sufficient evidence supported the jury's decision. Phillips also rejected Cosby's argument that the damages were excessive. Cosby has since appealed the trial finding, according to The New York Times.
A Separate Contempt Fight Over the Judgment
Motsinger's own efforts to collect the money have continued apart from Tarshis's new filing. A hearing on her contempt request is scheduled for January 2027, per the same Complex report. The Times has also reported that Motsinger's lawyers raised concern that Cosby and his family had moved assets around in ways that could hinder their ability to collect the judgment in the past.
Cosby's Health and Legal Standing
Cosby's attorney, Jennifer Bonjean, said in July that Cosby is legally blind and has health issues including significant mobility limitations, and that he could not attend scheduled depositions as a result. Cosby denies the allegations of sexual misconduct made against him. His earlier Pennsylvania criminal conviction was overturned in 2021 after he had served nearly three years in prison.









