West Michigan/ Crime & Emergencies

Dropped ID Cracks Elkhart Robbery Case, Lands Suspect Behind Bars

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Dropped ID Cracks Elkhart Robbery Case, Lands Suspect Behind Bars300 E. Crawford St. — Reported Altercation And Police Response
Google Street View

A dropped ID card turned out to be the undoing of a man Elkhart police say followed two women from a downtown bank and demanded their money. Demetrius Sturgis, 28, was arrested on Nov. 17 in connection with an attempted robbery and battery investigation, and he remains jailed without bond ahead of an initial hearing.

According to a report by WSBT, two women told officers that Sturgis followed them from Old National Bank and then ran up demanding money after they got out of their car. Officers were dispatched to 300 E. Crawford Street in Elkhart to investigate. The women refused to hand over any cash, and a fight broke out soon after.

Police say that during the struggle, Sturgis struck one of the women in the abdomen and repeatedly tried to grab her purse. Both women reported minor injuries and pain from the encounter, the station's report states. When Sturgis failed to get any money, he reportedly dropped several cards, including his own ID, and sped off in a Jeep.

Flock Cameras and a License Plate Seal the Case

That dropped identification proved critical. Investigators used Flock camera information to locate a Jeep Grand Cherokee matching the description the women gave, and from there obtained the vehicle's license plate number, per the same account. Around 5 p.m. that same day, an Elkhart police officer spotted a matching Jeep and conducted a traffic stop, leading to Sturgis being detained because he matched the ID left behind at the scene.

Sturgis, of Elkhart, was booked into the Elkhart County Jail the same day. A judicial officer found probable cause the next day, Nov. 18, for preliminary charges of one count of attempted robbery, a Level 3 felony, and two counts of battery, each a Class A misdemeanor, the article notes.

Suspect Held Without Bond Ahead of Court Date

The judicial officer ordered Sturgis held without bond until his initial hearing, scheduled for Nov. 24. The case has since been forwarded to the Elkhart County Prosecutor's Office for review of formal criminal charges, according to the City of Elkhart. As with any pending case, Sturgis is presumed innocent until proven guilty under Indiana law.

The Elkhart Police Department also shared details of the arrest in a Facebook news release posted the evening of Nov. 18. What happens at Sturgis's upcoming initial hearing, and whether the prosecutor's office will file formal charges, remains to be seen.