Tampa/ Crime & Emergencies

Dunnellon Man, 79, Vanishes in Red Miata — Silver Alert Issued After Welfare Check Fails

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Dunnellon Man, 79, Vanishes in Red Miata — Silver Alert Issued After Welfare Check Fails8029 SW 185th Ave. Rd. — Approximate Site of Welfare Check
Google Street View

A Silver Alert is out for Barry Allen Toll, a 79-year-old Dunnellon man who vanished sometime after October 18 and could not be found when deputies showed up to check on him Tuesday. Investigators say he may be dealing with a mental health or medical issue, and he is believed to be traveling in a red 2023 Mazda Miata MX5 with Florida plate FSIG15; his destination and direction of travel remain unknown.

The Marion County Sheriff's Office issued the alert after deputies were unable to locate Toll during a well-being check at his home, according to WFTV. Deputies visited his residence at 8029 SW 185th Avenue Road in Dunnellon, the station reports, but found no sign of him. The sheriff's office says Toll had last been heard from on October 18.

The Florida Department of Law Enforcement has also issued a statewide Silver Alert for Toll, who is listed as 79 years old and last known to be in Dunnellon, per Boca Post. He is described as a white male with white hair and brown eyes, standing about 6 feet tall and weighing roughly 200 pounds, the outlet notes.

Red Miata the Only Lead So Far

Toll is believed to be traveling in a red 2023 Mazda Miata MX5 bearing Florida license plate FSIG15, according to the same WFTV report. Investigators have not said where he might be headed or which direction he may have traveled, leaving the search without a clear starting point. The sheriff's office said Toll may be experiencing a mental health or medical issue, though no further details on that assessment have been released.

Boca Post reports that the Marion County Sheriff's Office is the local agency fielding tips in the case. Anyone with information is asked to contact the sheriff's office at 352-732-8181, while the WFTV report notes that tipsters can also call 911 directly.

Other Marion County Silver Alerts Have Ended Safely

Marion County has issued similar alerts before, with mixed timelines but some encouraging outcomes. A 72-year-old Dunnellon man, Billy Bowen, left home at about 7:30 a.m.

In a more recent case, the sheriff's office issued a Silver Alert in 2024 for 77-year-old Ronald Arthur Schor after he missed a VA clinic appointment in Ocala, according to Ocala-News.com. Schor's truck was later spotted heading southbound in Manatee County before he was reported located and safe. No comparable update has been issued yet in Toll's case, and his exact condition remains unclear.

Tampa-Crime & Emergencies