Seattle/ Crime & Emergencies

Eagle River Nurse Sentenced to 26 Years for Three Overdose Deaths

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
Eagle River Nurse Sentenced to 26 Years for Three Overdose DeathsSource: Utah Reps / Wikimedia Commons

Jessica Joyce Spayd, 55, a former advanced nurse practitioner in Eagle River, was sentenced Friday, November 13, to 26 years in federal prison for illegally prescribing and dispensing opioids and causing the overdose deaths of three patients.

The term follows a guilty plea, not the jury verdict that first sent her to prison. She admitted prescribing and dispensing opioids and other drugs outside the scope of her practice, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Alaska said. After that conviction was overturned, she agreed to plead guilty to causing the three deaths, Alaska Native News reported.

A Clinic That Purported to Treat Pain

For more than five years, Spayd operated what purported to be a legitimate clinic offering medical treatment for chronic pain and addiction. The authority in that chair was a prescription pad. The plea draws the line at how she used it: opioids and other drugs, dispensed outside the scope of her practice.

Between 2014 and 2019 she prescribed more than 4.4 million doses of opioid narcotics to roughly 450 patients, the Anchorage Daily News reported in its account of the June 2023 sentencing. Those years overlap the run of the clinic. The figure comes from that earlier coverage. Set beside Friday's plea, it is the scale of prescribing already attached to her name when the case first reached a sentence.

A 30-Year Sentence, Then a Recusal

In June 2023, then-U.S. District Judge Joshua M. Kindred sentenced Spayd to 30 years in prison, followed by three years of supervised release. A jury had convicted her. On paper, the case was finished.

The paper did not hold. The conviction and sentence were overturned because Kindred, now a former U.S. district judge, erroneously failed to recuse himself from Spayd's case, Alaska Native News reported. She then entered an agreement with the government to plead guilty to causing three overdose deaths.

Friday's 26 years is the sentence on that plea, four years shorter than the prison term Kindred imposed. One judgment was vacated. The other rests on the guilty plea. The recusal failure is why the case came back. It is not a ruling that the deaths had been miscounted.

Five Deaths Charged, Three Admitted

The toll has been described in more than one way, and the differences matter. In the 2023 coverage, Spayd was officially charged in five deaths stemming from her opioid prescriptions, while prosecutors said her actions contributed to 20 confirmed deaths. Those claims belonged to the prosecution Kindred sentenced. That conviction is gone.

What she admitted this time is three overdose deaths, and that is what Friday's sentence addresses. DEA Special Agent in Charge Robert A. Saccone said the conduct caused three patient deaths and contributed to at least 20 confirmed drug overdoses. His 20 counts overdoses. The prosecutors' 20, from 2023, counted deaths. The five was a charging figure in a judgment that did not stand.

A Statewide Drop After the Arrest

Assistant U.S. Attorney Ryan Tansey said two years after Spayd's arrest, opioid prescriptions in Alaska declined by 30 percent, or 1.3 million pills, in that same 2023 sentencing coverage. He placed the drop next to her arrest. The number is statewide prescriptions in the two years after that arrest. It is not a slice of the 4.4 million doses attributed to her own patients from 2014 to 2019.

"DEA will not tolerate medical professionals who exploit their licenses and positions of trust to operate as drug dealers," Saccone said. "We will aggressively pursue those who abuse their prescribing authority, endanger patients, and fuel the opioid crisis."

The sentence under that warning is 26 years. Spayd was 55 when it was imposed, on a plea to three deaths.