Denver/ Politics & Govt

Elbert County Weighs 5,700-Acre Data Center as Water Fight Splits Residents

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Elbert County Weighs 5,700-Acre Data Center as Water Fight Splits Residents215 Comanche St. — Local Street Scene
Google Street View

Elbert County commissioners spent hours this week hearing from residents on both sides of a proposal to rezone roughly 5,700 acres of agricultural land for a massive data center, part of a plan known as Colorado Plains Ranch. More than 40 community members spoke at the meeting, with written comments submitted by another few dozen people, before commissioners recessed shortly after 6 p.m. without reaching a decision.

The hearing, reported by Denver7, centered on a plan to rezone the site in the eastern part of Elbert County, off Route 86 near Interstate 70, from agricultural to heavy industrial use. The Colorado Plains Ranch project would include a 540-megawatt data center along with on-site natural gas and renewable energy generation, battery storage, biochar production, and regenerative agriculture, according to Rocky Mountain PBS. Commissioners planned to resume the meeting at 9 a.m. Thursday.

Developer Touts Tax Windfall, Residents Question Water Use

Bill Rigler, a spokesperson for the developer, told commissioners the project would provide major financial benefits while avoiding the problems that have plagued traditional data centers elsewhere, per Denver7's reporting. He said an independent third-party firm estimated the project would generate about $79 million in new property tax revenue each year, nearly tripling the county's current annual tax take. Rigler said the projected revenues could cover property taxes for every Elbert County resident and still leave an additional $50 million in annual revenue.

Rigler also said the data center would use closed-loop cooling technology that circulates water repeatedly, rather than the evaporative cooling systems used by older data centers in Virginia, Ohio and Texas, which he said consume millions of gallons of water each year. He put the project's first-phase water needs at roughly 500,000 gallons of imported water, and said none of that water would come from a Denver Water aquifer. The project's own website separately states the development would use approximately 500,000 gallons in total through its closed-loop system, Rocky Mountain PBS reports.

Resident Raises Concerns About Water Table and Preferential Treatment

Stephanie Dieck, an Elbert County resident, told commissioners that developers are requesting 188 acre-feet of water per year, which she said equals roughly 60 million gallons. Dieck argued that if the project is approved, the county would have little power to limit its water use, since the county cannot restrict water use or water rights once water is being used within the county, nor can it restrict building permits based on water rights or water usage.

Dieck raised concerns that shallow groundwater near the site could mean pumping continues even after nearby wells run dry, and she said the water table is connected throughout Colorado, meaning the project could affect the entire state. The proposed site sits near the Big Sandy River. Dieck said a data center should not receive preferential treatment amid drought and water restrictions, though she clarified she opposes the current proposal rather than data centers in general.

Separately, Rocky Mountain PBS reports that Colorado Plains Ranch, LLC applied for groundwater rights from the Laramie-Fox Hills aquifer, and that the county's 300-year rule caps the ranch's maximum annual use at 187 acre-feet. The project developer has said the data center's water would instead come from an offsite industrial facility rather than that aquifer. At a May community meeting, the project team fielded questions on water, power, noise and oversight but made no formal commitments on water permits, power contracts, investor identities or enforceable operational caps, according to Citizen Portal.

Planning Commission Already Recommended Approval

The debate follows a separate vote by the Elbert County Planning Commission, which on Nov. 5 voted 6-2 to recommend approval of the planned unit development after more than 100 residents attended its Nov. 4 meeting, per Rocky Mountain PBS. That same report notes that natural gas and coal together generated about 58% of U.S. electricity in 2025, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, a backdrop to the project's planned on-site gas generation.

Elbert County is not the only Colorado county wrestling with how to handle data center proposals. In Logan County, commissioners adopted a six-month moratorium in October 2025 on data centers, utility-scale solar and battery installations while they worked out regulations, Big Pivots reports. After hearing from a dozen speakers, those commissioners tabled further regulations until Feb. 17, with one commissioner noting that conditions can still be imposed project by project during the special-use permit process.

Other jurisdictions have taken different approaches. Douglas County leaders granted a $19 million business personal property tax break to a Flexential data center under construction in Parker, its fifth facility in Colorado, according to CBS Colorado, which notes that some municipalities statewide are instead passing outright moratoriums. In Georgetown, Texas, more than 100 residents spoke out against a proposed data center, and the city's planning and zoning commission unanimously recommended denying the rezoning request, though developers could still bring that proposal before the city council in December, per KXAN.

Back in Elbert County, no decision has been made on the Colorado Plains Ranch rezoning. Commissioners are set to pick the discussion back up Thursday morning.