Pittsburgh/ Crime & Emergencies

Elizabeth Township Threatens to Pull School Police Coverage Over Chief's Ban

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Elizabeth Township Threatens to Pull School Police Coverage Over Chief's Ban401 Rock Run Rd. — District That Received Township Letter
Google Street View

Elizabeth Township has warned the Elizabeth Forward School District that it could lose police coverage for school bus duties after the school board moved to keep the township police chief off the grounds of Central Elementary School. A letter dated Nov. 3 from township solicitor Matthew Racunas laid out two paths forward, and the school board could decide which one it takes at a voting meeting scheduled for Wednesday, November 18.

Township Says It Learned of the Ban and Pushed Back

According to WTAE, the Nov. 3 letter states that the township became aware of the school board's decision to preclude the police chief from entering the elementary school property. Racunas, who serves as the township's solicitor, wrote that the township retains sole discretion over the assignment of its officers, effectively pushing back on the board's attempt to dictate which officer can be on campus. TribLIVE, which first reported the dispute, identified the letter as having been sent to Superintendent Keith Konyk at the beginning of November.

The letter reportedly gave the district an ultimatum: confirm in writing whether it accepts the township's continued police coverage, or risk losing it. If the district accepts, the station's report notes that the township will continue providing coverage for morning and afternoon bus duties, a service the township has offered at no cost to the district, and the chief would remain able to patrol all locations in his jurisdiction, including Central Elementary. If the district declines, per the same account, the township will end that complimentary bus-duty coverage and reduce police presence during those times to responding only to calls and emergencies.

A Lawsuit and an Intimidation Claim Sit Behind the Dispute

The standoff traces back to a defamation lawsuit involving two school board members, one reportedly identified as an Elizabeth Township police officer and the other as the police chief, stemming from allegations made during their campaigns for school board seats, the outlet reported. A Central Elementary employee who is a witness in that lawsuit has reportedly said she feels intimidated by the chief's presence on campus, according to the same report.

Board member Tom Sharkey told TribLIVE the matter should have been handled internally rather than becoming public, calling it political. Sharkey, who said he was sharing his opinion individually rather than on behalf of the board or district, said executive sessions and personnel matters require confidentiality, discretion and respect, and that board members disregarding that confidentiality undermines trust in governance. He said public service should prioritize students, employees and taxpayers over personal agendas and political disputes, and that dysfunction and chaos have plagued the board over the past year.

Board Secretary Points to a Yearlong Pattern of Conflict

Board secretary Scott Henry told TribLIVE he would not comment on the specifics of the personnel matter but described the situation as reflecting a much larger problem facing the board. Henry said personal and professional conflicts have overshadowed the board's work for more than a year and pointed to embarrassing dysfunction and personal animosity among members. As of TribLIVE's reporting, the board had taken no action yet regarding police coverage at the elementary school, per Henry.

Henry said the board is also managing a school consolidation affecting the entire district community and believes that process should be the board's main focus, adding that employee safety concerns can be addressed while still protecting districtwide safety. He said students and taxpayers deserve better leadership and judgment. Sharkey separately said administrators should focus on education and employee support rather than unnecessary controversies, and that the situation reflects failures of leadership, accountability and respect.

Wider Tensions Have Simmered on the Board for Months

This is not the first flashpoint involving the school board's ties to township police. WTAE previously reported that Elizabeth Township police Sgt. Jamie Evans, who also serves as the Elizabeth Forward school board president, was placed on leave and under investigation following an alleged confrontation with Sharkey. The district's own staff directory lists its school resource officer partnership with Elizabeth Township Police as providing two officers, Dan Novacek and Jose Estevez, according to Elizabeth Forward School District.

The district has previously described broader safety efforts, including security guards stationed in its buildings and a planned safety task force meant to study practices at other districts before making recommendations to the board, according to the Mon Valley Independent. The board is simultaneously weighing a consolidation plan that would shift kindergarten and first grade into Central Elementary and move grades two through six to the current middle school while putting the Greenock/Mt. Vernon and William Penn buildings up for sale, the paper has reported, though no final vote on selling or consolidating elementary schools had been taken as of a packed meeting last November.

Elizabeth Forward's superintendent's office has not returned TribLIVE's request for comment on the police coverage dispute. Wednesday's board meeting is where a vote on the matter could take place, though what the board ultimately decides remains to be seen.