
Nassau County has struck a deal with the federal government to shut down 14 large cesspools that officials say could contaminate the drinking water lying beneath Long Island, with closure deadlines stretching out to July 2028 and the county agreeing to pay $100,000 to settle the case.
The settlement, reported by Newsday, resolves government allegations that Nassau violated the 1974 Safe Drinking Water Act and a 2005 mandate requiring the county to close large cesspools. In a legal filing, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency said the cesspools release wastewater from county park bathrooms, visitors centers and recreational facilities into underground soil sitting above the aquifer that supplies Long Island's drinking water, according to the outlet's reporting.
The government said in the filing that unsanitary waste from large-capacity cesspools poses a serious risk to public health because it can enter groundwater and contaminate drinking-water sources, the newspaper reported. An EPA representative said the agreement will deliver environmental protections for Nassau County residents and that the agency looks forward to working with the county as it closes the cesspools, per the same account.
Deadlines Along the North Shore
Under the settlement, Nassau must meet a series of deadlines to shut down cesspools along the county's North Shore. A cesspool beneath Bailey Arboretum in Locust Valley must be inoperable by July 2028, while at least one cesspool at Muttontown Preserve was set to close during the week the settlement was reported. Muttontown, the outlet noted, has a median household income of nearly a quarter-million dollars.
The government named five cesspools at Muttontown Preserve, located two beneath Nassau Hall and two under Chelsea Mansion, the report said. Separately, the lawsuit named four cesspools at Sands Point Preserve, with one located at the Children's Learning Center and another at Hempstead House, according to the same reporting.
Missing deadlines or reporting mandates could cost Nassau County up to $750 per violation per day, the settlement terms show. That penalty jumps to $2,000 per day after 60 days of non-compliance, the paper reported, raising the financial stakes for the county if the closure timeline slips.
A Yearslong Federal Push Predates Blakeman
The settlement follows a yearslong federal effort to decommission Nassau's large cesspools that began before Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman's tenure, the outlet reported. Blakeman said the county continues working with the EPA to update septic systems at acquired properties, and said the updates benefit infrastructure and taxpayers' health and safety, calling the deal an environmental victory for Nassau County, according to Newsday's reporting.
Suffolk County officials, meanwhile, have been working for years to replace every polluting septic tank and cesspool across that county, the newspaper noted, suggesting the cesspool problem is not confined to Nassau's borders. A 2023 case in Suffolk ended with the county agreeing to a $200,000 civil penalty after the government alleged its ongoing operation of large cesspools and vehicle waste wells violated the Safe Drinking Water Act, according to Reuters.
Why Islanders Are Watching Their Water
A recent Newsday/Siena poll found that residents consider contaminated drinking water Long Island's greatest risk over the next 10 years, underscoring why the cesspool settlement resonates beyond the handful of parks named in the case. Adrienne Esposito, executive director of the Citizens Campaign for the Environment, said 100% of Long Island's drinking water comes from underground, and that septic systems and cesspools pollute that water while also flowing into the marine environment, including bays, harbors and estuaries.
The concern tracks with broader data on the island's wastewater problem. Nitrogen released into soil and groundwater from wastewater systems is a recognized threat to water quality across Long Island, according to Long Island Press, which also reported that Nassau County's SEPTIC Replacement Program grants eligible property owners up to $20,000 for nitrogen-reducing septic upgrades. The outlet noted that the Nassau County Legislature and environmental groups have celebrated the program reaching its 100th installation of an alternative onsite wastewater treatment system.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has separately described large-capacity cesspools as devices serving multiple dwellings or communities that receive sanitary waste containing human excreta and have an open bottom, sometimes with perforated sides, according to the agency's own compliance guidance.









