
Erewhon, the Los Angeles grocery chain famous for its sky-high smoothie prices, is opening its first public tonic bar in New York City this Friday, tucked inside the Kith Women’s flagship store in NoHo. The spot at 644 Broadway opens from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. EST and will run seven days a week, serving signature tonics, superfood smoothies, bowls, juices, cold-pressed shots, coffee and ceremonial-grade matcha to anyone who walks in, not just paying club members.
From Private Club to Public Storefront
The move marks a shift from Erewhon’s quieter debut in the city late last year, when it opened a drinks-only outpost inside the private Kith Ivy club in the West Village, according to New York Post. That setup, described by Eater NY as a drinks-only outpost or “tonic bar,” was available in person only to Kith Ivy members, who pay a $45,000 initiation fee and $10,000 in annual dues.
Nonmembers weren’t entirely shut out, though. The Kith Ivy Tonic Bar offered delivery through Postmates and Uber Eats, with drinks limited to small quantities and orders capped within a one-mile radius of the bar. Per People, that delivery-only service launched on November 19, 2025, letting fans within roughly a mile of the West Village order Erewhon smoothies, with an original launch menu featuring the Strawberry Glaze Skin Smoothie, Malibu Mango, Coconut Cloud and Vanilla Matcha.
Sign Spotted, Then Covered Up
Speculation about a bigger New York presence had been building for weeks. Erewhon has said the opening was rumored after signage sightings spread on social media last month, and the same Eater NY report notes that Snaxshot’s Andrea Hernández shared a photo of a recognizable Erewhon sign at 644 Broadway and Bleecker Street on October 23 — only for the signage to be covered up again just hours later. At the time, Inc. reported that it was possible a new location would follow the same drinks-only format as Kith Ivy, but that had not been confirmed.
Now Erewhon has confirmed on its official Instagram account that its first public New York tonic bar will open inside the Kith Women’s store. Erewhon CEO Tony Antoci said New York has felt like a natural place for Erewhon to grow, while Erewhon Vice President Josephine Antoci said the new concept will bring Erewhon’s experience to a broader community while maintaining its values and standards. One would-be customer reacted to the announcement with a simple: “I’m gonna cry.”
A Smoothie With a Cause
The NoHo location will carry a Kith Women store-exclusive drink called the Erewhon State of Mind smoothie, made with organic cold-pressed apple juice, winter spices and goji berries. Sales of that smoothie will support the Bowery Mission, an organization that helps New Yorkers experiencing homelessness and other crises.
Erewhon’s prices have long been part of its mystique and its backlash. The chain’s take on Hailey Bieber’s Strawberry Glaze Skin Smoothie costs $21 at most Los Angeles locations, and Eater NY reports that tonic-bar smoothies in New York start at $18 and climb past $26 for some drinks. The same report notes that copycat versions made with streaky vegan cream and fruit had already started popping up at East Village spots like Organic and Oases by 2024, well before Erewhon itself arrived.
Why Erewhon Is Betting Big Right Now
Founded in 1966 and named after an 1872 utopian novel — itself an anagram for “nowhere” — Erewhon has grown from a single store into a Los Angeles cult grocery brand that became a status symbol around 2020. The company now runs 13 full-fledged grocery stores in California and has called its latest growth phase “Erewhon 2.0,” with the Los Angeles Times reporting that the chain opened its 15th store, in Thousand Oaks, as its first location outside L.A. County. That Thousand Oaks store featured its own exclusive smoothie, with some proceeds benefiting the Manna Conejo Food Bank. The paper reports the Pacific Palisades store is set to reopen after closing because of a wildfire; stores in downtown L.A. and Costa Mesa are scheduled to open in June and September 2027.
Whether that formula translates three thousand miles east is an open question among retail watchers. A Rutgers marketing professor told Inc. that much of Erewhon’s appeal in Los Angeles is tied to the city’s wellness culture and the status associated with being seen there, and that the brand would need to become part of New Yorkers’ everyday routines to succeed. An Emory consumer behavior scholar put it more bluntly to the outlet, saying Erewhon is selling a certain kind of L.A. identity, “wellness as lifestyle,” that extends beyond groceries — and New York, the scholar noted, runs on its own status codes.









