
Erie County auditors say 3,871 transactions totaling $4,808,983.09 never made it into the Seneca Babcock Community Association's accounting records from 2021 through 2025. The same review raised questions about tax filings, documentation and financial controls around county money.
That figure is an omission from the books, not a finding that the money was stolen or lost. The South Shore Press reported that auditors did not conclude the $4.8 million was stolen or lost, and did not establish that any individual committed wrongdoing. WGRZ likewise reported that the missing transactions and financial concerns do not establish theft or wrongdoing.
What the Books Did Not Show
The audit covered transactions from 2021 through 2025 and identified questionable tax filings and inadequate financial controls. It also raised questions about how the Buffalo association managed Erie County funding.
The holes were not limited to the five-year transaction list. Auditors could not get enough documentation to reconcile a reported $1 million building-fund contribution from 2017, or to determine how that money was ultimately spent.
A sample of county payments was also incomplete on the association's side of the ledger. Auditors could not fully reconcile $327,600 paid to Seneca Babcock or Schiller Park Community Services with accounting records.
Filings That Did Not Match the Years
The tax paperwork has its own timeline problem. Buffalo Toronto Public Media reported that the association last submitted a Form 990 in 2020, and that filing covered tax year 2017.
Financial information later submitted as purported tax returns for 2019, 2020 and 2021 duplicated figures from that 2017 return, according to The South Shore Press. The Buffalo News reported that the association attached an IRS form to a county grant application that it had never filed with the federal government.
Former executive director Brian Pilarski acknowledged that he had failed to submit required Form 990 filings to the IRS for several years, WGRZ reported. He resigned from the post.
Under IRS rules, tax-exempt status is automatically revoked when an organization fails to file the required Form 990-series return or notice for three consecutive years. Reporting on Seneca Babcock does not agree on the year the association's federal exemption ended, so the audit record is clearer on the filings than on a single revocation date.
Grants After the Exemption Question
Status mattered because much of the county funding was conditioned on it. Of 39 Erie County funding arrangements examined, at least 25 required charitable nonprofit status.
Nine grant applications submitted after the revocation affirmatively represented that Seneca Babcock still maintained its federal tax exemption, The South Shore Press reported. Eric Tower, a special assistant commissioner in the Erie County Department of Social Services, told county legislators in April 2026 that the county continued approving taxpayer-funded grants after the association lost nonprofit recognition. He confirmed nine grants totaling about $110,000 since June 2021.
A Referral, Not a Theft Case
Erie County referred the Seneca-Babcock Community Association to the District Attorney's Office over documents the county described as misleading about its IRS standing, The Buffalo News reported. The referral is about those documents. It is not, on the published record, a completed prosecution or a finding that anyone took the omitted funds.
A Wider Nonprofit Review
Schiller Park Community Services had its own federal tax-exempt status revoked in 2018. County records showed it received more than $1.5 million in payments between 2015 and 2021.
The Comptroller's Office has also flagged El Batey, a cultural organization serving low-income Puerto Rican youth and families, for financial issues, The Buffalo News reported. That flag is a separate case. It does show the county review reaching beyond one association's ledger.
For Seneca Babcock, the concrete result so far is a $4,808,983.09 gap in the 2021–2025 books, unreconciled county payments, duplicated return figures, and a referral over documents the county says misstated IRS standing. Auditors stopped short of calling the money stolen.









