
A former managing director at Compass Development Marketing has sued the firm, claiming he was frozen out of its most lucrative accounts and ultimately fired because of his age and sex. Gary Cicerello, who worked at the company from 2023 to 2026, says Naftali Group projects, which he claims made up 60 to 75 percent of the firm's business, were steered instead to a colleague with younger support staff while his own teams were stripped of resources.
Cicerello, 62, filed the lawsuit in the Southern District of New York, according to The Real Deal, naming Compass, its new development group, and co-heads of new development Dan Parker and Sarah Patton as defendants. The complaint alleges Parker managed the Naftali portfolio alongside two women decades younger than Cicerello, and that Parker and Patton directed career development, staffing resources, mentorship and advancement opportunities toward employees under 40.
A Portfolio Stripped of Naftali Business
While Parker's team handled the bulk of the Naftali Group pipeline, Cicerello was left overseeing a non-Naftali portfolio that included 33 Park Row, 250 West 96th Street and The Katharine at 118 West 13th Street. The complaint alleges senior employees like Cicerello were deprived of project-management resources even as those buildings moved toward sellout. The Katharine, notably, sold all eight of its units in under a year, and 33 Park Row had just two of its 30 units left to sell, per the same report.
Not every project in his portfolio fared as well. A Corcoran team took over sales for 250 West 96th Street in May, according to StreetEasy, and the building remains roughly one-third unsold, according to Marketproof. Cicerello claims that two project managers on his portfolio resigned in 2025 and that an administrator for 250 West 96th Street left at the start of 2026, leaving him with what he described as virtually no project-management or administrative support.
Eliminated Role, Reassigned Staff
The developer eliminated the on-site administrator role for 33 Park Row at the end of 2025, and the employee in that position was later reassigned to Parker's projects, the lawsuit alleges. A senior project manager who had overseen 33 Park Row was separately reassigned to Sarah Patton's rental projects. Cicerello claims these staffing shifts left his buildings thinner on support while Parker and Patton's teams gained personnel.
Cicerello was fired in February, and he alleges the reasons the company gave were pretextual. Those cited reasons included discrepancies in what was available at 250 West 96th Street and incorrect Fair Housing and Agency Disclosure forms; Dan Parker reportedly also cited an incorrect development report shared with the team for 33 Park Row. Cicerello contends the real cause was discrimination compounded by inadequate staffing support, and he further claims that Compass's market position has made it difficult for him to land a new job. A spokesperson for Compass declined to comment.
What Cicerello Is Seeking
The lawsuit seeks back pay and, rather than reinstatement, front pay, along with compensatory damages for emotional distress and professional harm and liquidated damages tied to alleged violations of federal age discrimination law. Federal law under 29 U.S.C. § 623 makes it unlawful for an employer to base a preference, limitation, specification or discrimination on age.
The case lands as Compass has grown into a dominant force in residential real estate. The company acquired Anywhere Real Estate for $1.6 billion in January, combining the two largest brokerages in the country by sales volume, a scale Cicerello claims has made it harder for him to find comparable work elsewhere since his termination.
A Development Marketing Team on the Rise
Compass Development Marketing Group's new-development business, which Cicerello says relied heavily on Naftali Group projects, had been expanding rapidly in recent years. Parker told Resident in 2024 that demand for larger apartments, particularly four-bedroom-plus homes on the Upper East and Upper West Sides, continued to grow, while Patton said buyers were prioritizing conveniences like on-site parking and electric-vehicle charging alongside luxury amenities. That same 2024 piece noted full sellouts and record prices at projects including The Benson, 200 East 83rd Street, The Bellemont and 150 East 78th Street, highlighting a $68 million sale at The Bellemont on Madison Avenue as a milestone. Compass Development Marketing has also worked with Naftali Group on several projects and has launched sales at buildings including The Henry at 211 West 84th Street, The Willow at 201 East 23rd Street and 255 East 77th Street.









