Las Vegas/ Politics & Govt

Ex-Nevada Investigator Sues Aguilar, Ford Over Secret Dishonesty Label

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Ex-Nevada Investigator Sues Aguilar, Ford Over Secret Dishonesty LabelNevada Secretary of State’s Office — Former Workplace of Plaintiff
Google Street View

A former criminal investigator for the Nevada secretary of state’s office says he was branded dishonest, stripped of his job, and never told what he supposedly did wrong — so now he is suing the state’s two top elected legal officials to find out. William Morciglio III has filed suit against Secretary of State Francisco Aguilar and Attorney General Aaron Ford, alleging he was denied any real chance to challenge a designation that could harm his career and affect challenges to his testimony.

According to the lawsuit, as reported by the Las Vegas Review-Journal, Morciglio has never been told what specifically he was dishonest about. The suit says the allegations appear to stem from his November 2024 arrest in Las Vegas on suspicion of DUI, a case in which he ultimately pleaded no contest to reckless driving before the charges were dismissed. The dishonesty label, his attorneys argue, could haunt him going forward because opposing attorneys could use it to attack his credibility as a witness in future cases.

Morciglio joined the secretary of state’s office as an investigator in April and passed his six-month performance evaluation, the lawsuit states. Things fell apart at a September 29 proceeding, where the suit says he was given no meaningful opportunity to examine the evidence behind the dishonesty claim or to present anything in his own defense. The chief deputy secretary of state, identified in the suit as C. Murphy Hebert, reviewed Morciglio’s release from probationary employment that day without ever determining whether the underlying dishonesty allegation was even accurate. The written determination labeled his release non-disciplinary, according to the lawsuit.

How the Allegation Surfaced

Andrew Regenbaum, who represents Morciglio through the Nevada Association of Public Safety Officers, said a supervisor in the attorney general’s office prepared a memo during the time of Morciglio’s arrest and placed it in his personnel file without his knowledge. Regenbaum said the document did not surface until Morciglio submitted cases for prosecution that the attorney general’s office later rejected — the first sign, he said, that something was working against him behind the scenes.

Regenbaum also said the secretary of state’s office was aware of the DUI arrest and the surrounding investigation and had been in contact with the attorney general’s office about it. Still, Regenbaum said, “One of the key points in the case is that no one is clear on that.”

Seeking a Name-Clearing Hearing

Morciglio’s attorneys are asking the court for an injunction that would require Aguilar’s office to grant him a formal name-clearing hearing. The request goes further than that: it also asks the court to force Ford’s office to participate in that hearing and to produce the evidence actually supporting the dishonesty allegation, rather than letting the designation stand unexplained.

Regenbaum said the public safety officers’ association has pushed back on untruthfulness designations through arbitration before, in cases covered by collective bargaining agreements that let officers view the allegations against them and defend themselves either within their agency or in front of an arbitrator. This marks the first time, he said, that the organization has gone to court over one. He argued that a judicial proceeding is the right venue to settle whether an actual finding of untruthfulness even exists in Morciglio’s case.

Secretary of State’s Office spokesperson Cecilia Heston said Aguilar’s office was unaware of the lawsuit because it had not yet been served, and she declined to comment further on personnel matters. The attorney general’s office did not respond to a request for comment from the Review-Journal.

A Recurring Fight Over Hidden Officer Files

Nevada law, under NRS 289.040, generally restricts placing unfavorable comments or documents in a peace officer’s administrative file without giving the officer a chance to read, respond to, and review it, according to the Nevada Legislature’s own index for Chapter 289 of the Nevada Revised Statutes.

Disputes over so-called credibility lists for law enforcement are not unique to Nevada, though the specific rules and procedures elsewhere do not necessarily apply here. A Brady list is meant to flag for courts when an officer who might testify has a credibility problem, but a WGCU investigation found the U.S. Supreme Court never set concrete guidelines for what kind of misconduct earns a spot on one, leaving standards to vary by jurisdiction. In Florida’s Fourth Judicial Circuit, WGCU found 89 officers across Duval, Clay, and Nassau counties on such a list, with 17 flagged specifically for departures from the truth.

In Wisconsin, a TMJ4 investigation identified 138 current and former officers across 10 southeastern counties flagged for issues ranging from dishonesty to bias to past crimes, with 81% of those flagged tied to alleged untruthfulness. One Dodge County deputy featured in that reporting said he was placed on a Brady list over a lie about his age told decades before he ever became a deputy, and that he was given no appeal process to fight the designation. Milwaukee County’s district attorney later removed seven names from a Brady list after TMJ4 inquired about them, the station reported.

Those cases illustrate a broader pattern of officers struggling to contest credibility labels once they are applied, even as the mechanics of Nevada’s dispute remain distinct. For now, Morciglio’s case rests on whether a federal court will order the hearing his attorneys say he was denied — one where, for the first time, he could see and respond to whatever evidence exists behind the word “dishonest” attached to his name.