
A federal appeals panel in Jacksonville spent part of Monday pressing the University of Florida on exactly what threat it saw in a law student's online post about Jewish people, as the university tries to keep Preston Damsky expelled from its Levin College of Law. Damsky, who has described himself as a white nationalist, was expelled after posting on X that “Jews must be abolished by any means necessary.” UF says that statement disrupted the law school's daily functioning and threatened students; a lower court sided with Damsky, and now the fight is before the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The case landed before the appeals panel on Nov. 16 in Jacksonville, where judges pushed back on UF's allegations that Damsky's post amounted to a threat, according to the Gainesville Sun. Christopher Bartolomucci, representing the University of Florida, told the panel the UF community saw the post as threatening violence to the school's large Jewish population, and argued that abolishing meant eliminating Jews and constituted a threat. Judge Adalberto Jordan, who was appointed to the court by former President Barack Obama, cut in with a blunt question: “What violence?”
Anthony Sabatini, representing Damsky, argued there was no true threat of violence in his client's post. He told the panel Damsky had no apparent ability to carry out what he said, that it was not imminent, and that he was not targeting anyone, adding that Damsky was not creating a reasonable fear. Sabatini argued that Damsky's online political speech is protected by the First Amendment, and UF's attorney countered that the post was a threat that disrupted the learning environment.
How a Lower Court Ordered Damsky Reinstated
Damsky was suspended during his second year of law school, months before he filed his lawsuit against the university in September 2025. U.S. District Judge Allen Winsor later ordered Damsky's reinstatement, finding that his view was protected by the First Amendment despite being hateful and offensive. According to a court order reviewed in the case, Winsor concluded at the preliminary-injunction stage that the university had not shown that any of Damsky's speech constituted a “true threat.”
That order directed the university official named in it to take appropriate steps to return Damsky to normal standing by Dec. 1, 2025, but only after Damsky posted a $2,500 bond. The 11th Circuit then paused Damsky's return to classes while the appeal played out. As Reuters reported, the appeals court's majority cited a “strong public interest” in mitigating campus violence when it put Winsor's ruling on hold.
Conflicting Timelines on the Post and the Expulsion
Accounts differ on key dates in the case. The Gainesville Sun reported that Damsky posted the statement in April 2025, while a district court document places the same post on March 21, 2025. The timelines also diverge on when Damsky's expulsion took effect: the Gainesville Sun reported he was expelled in August 2025, while Reuters reported UF expelled him in October. A separate court document states that a panel rejected Damsky's appeal and his expulsion became final on Oct. 9, 2025, though it is not clear from the record how that date relates to the earlier reported expulsion dates.
What a Gainesville Attorney Says the Law Requires
Gary Edinger, a Gainesville First Amendment attorney, said a true threat requires that Damsky reasonably should have known people would fear his posts. That standard sits at the center of the dispute, since UF has argued the post itself was the threat while Damsky's side insists nothing in his history or conduct made the statement one people should have reasonably feared.
The case may test the bounds of how far a public university can go in disciplining students for controversial online speech, a question that comes as debates over free speech on university campuses have intensified during President Donald Trump's second term, per Reuters. The appeals court has not yet ruled on the merits of UF's appeal or on what becomes of Damsky's status at the law school.









