The FBI’s Oklahoma City bureau is asking the public for help solving a cold case out of Broken Arrow, offering up to $25,000 for information that leads to the recovery of Paige Moore or the arrest and conviction of whoever is responsible for her disappearance. Investigators are now focused on a specific green SUV and a handgun they believe are tied to the case, and they say they need the public’s memory to fill in the gaps.
According to KOKI FOX 23, federal agents are offering the reward for information leading to Moore’s recovery or the arrest and conviction of those responsible for her disappearance. Accounts differ on exactly when Moore vanished: the Fox23 report places her disappearance on July 10, 2011, while NewsOn6 reports she was last seen by family members on July 10, 2012, at her residence in Broken Arrow, when she was 17.
Broken Arrow police now call the case a homicide, the station’s report states. A separate account from KJRH says the Broken Arrow Police Department reactivated Moore’s case in July 2024 after receiving a pivotal tip, though it is not clear whether that reactivation is the same development driving this week’s reward announcement.
Investigators Zero In on a Green SUV
Broken Arrow police investigators have shared new information about a possible vehicle connected to Moore’s disappearance: a dark green 2002 Chevrolet Tracker. The FBI’s missing-person notice states that the Tracker, bearing Oklahoma plate 931KSW, may have been involved, though the notice’s own wording is conditional rather than conclusive.
Police say Arthur Carlson drove the Tracker in 2012. Per the same NewsOn6 account, the vehicle was later sold in 2015 to someone described as not involved in the case, then given to a man known only as Ramon for repairs in the Tulsa area. It hasn’t been registered since 2016, and investigators are hoping the public can help them track him down.
A Stolen Pistol Also Sought
Alongside the SUV, police are seeking information about a Ruger P89 9mm pistol, serial number 312-50111, that was reported stolen the same month Moore went missing. Neither the vehicle nor the firearm has been confirmed as recovered; KJRH reported that police were honing in on a suspect.
The scale of the investigation itself has been described differently across outlets. NewsOn6 reports that more than 100 people have been interviewed and multiple locations searched, while the Broken Arrow Sentinel reports police interviewed more than 70 people before reclassifying the case as a homicide. It is not clear from available reporting whether those figures reflect different stages or different scopes of the inquiry.
How to Submit a Tip
The FBI is directing anyone with information to call 405-290-7770 or submit an anonymous tip online at tips.fbi.gov. With the $25,000 reward now on the table, investigators are hoping fresh eyes — or a long-dormant memory of the green Tracker, Ramon, or the missing Ruger — might finally move the years-old case forward.
