
A former Baltimore City Fire Department paramedic has sued the city, claiming he was repeatedly suspended and ultimately fired for refusing to shave a beard he says his Muslim faith requires him to keep. Othmane El Omari joined the department on May 8, 2024, and the very next day asked for permission to maintain a religiously consistent beard — a request that, according to his lawsuit, set off nearly two years of conflict that ended with his termination this past March.
El Omari previously worked for Hart to Heart, a private emergency medical services company contracting with Baltimore, before joining the city department. According to the lawsuit, a human resources representative told him an accommodation would not be available until he completed training at the Baltimore City Fire Academy, so he shaved, fearing he would otherwise lose his job and believing the requirement was temporary. As reported by Firehouse, which cited the Baltimore Sun, he graduated from the academy in November 2024 and renewed his request for a beard accommodation soon after — only for the department to deny it again, citing its grooming standards.
A Goatee, a Chief's Order, and a Suspension
El Omari then grew a trimmed, goatee-style beard he believed would satisfy both his religious obligations and the department's safety equipment requirements, maintaining it for roughly six months without incident, according to the complaint. That changed in May 2025, when a chief reported his facial hair to Chief Maurice Taylor, who ordered him to shave. El Omari complied, then later regrew the beard.
The standoff escalated this past August. According to the complaint, Capt. Dimick warned El Omari on August 9 that he would face suspension unless he shaved, and El Omari refused, citing his faith. The following day, the department suspended him without pay for 48 work hours for insubordination. At an August 18 meeting with human resources director Nikki Lewis, El Omari requested an accommodation and volunteered for a respirator fit test — a procedure that would determine whether his beard interfered with the seal of his self-contained breathing apparatus self-contained breathing apparatus. According to the lawsuit, the department never conducted that test.
Termination and a Federal Complaint
El Omari spent roughly six months on suspension, much of it without pay, per the lawsuit, before the department fired him on March 18 — ending nearly two years of employment. The Council on American-Islamic Relations says it filed an EEOC complaint on his behalf in September 2025 challenging the department's refusal to accommodate his religious beliefs and its enforcement of the grooming policy, according to CAIR. CAIR says that effort failed to resolve the matter, and the department terminated him earlier this year regardless.
CAIR announced it has now filed a federal lawsuit on El Omari's behalf in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland on November 4, accusing Baltimore of violating federal civil rights law. The suit alleges three Title VII violations: failure to accommodate religion, discriminatory treatment resulting in wrongful termination, and unlawful retaliation — with Title VII having been enacted as part of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. CAIR's filing argues El Omari's firing amounted to unlawful retaliation for his repeated accommodation requests and his EEOC complaint, and the organization alleges numerous other employees, including supervisors, maintained facial hair throughout their employment while El Omari was disciplined.
Competing Accounts of the Fit-Test Dispute
CAIR says the department declined to administer a fit test to El Omari and instead subjected him to disciplinary action, a claim echoed by his attorneys, who say the department refused to conduct a test that could have determined whether his beard compromised his safety equipment. EMS1 reported the same gap, noting the department had not administered a fit test to El Omari and had instead enforced the policy against him. For its part, the fire department has said its grooming policy is needed to ensure a proper respirator seal, per EMS1's reporting, though it has not addressed why no fit test was given.
CAIR says El Omari sought a narrower accommodation — shaving only the area where a respirator seals against the skin and then submitting to fit testing — an approach it says OSHA itself contemplates. Federal OSHA standards bar employers from letting workers use a tight-fitting respirator if facial hair comes between the sealing surface and the face or interferes with valve function. But OSHA's own guidance clarifies that not all facial hair is disqualifying: short mustaches, sideburns, and small, neatly trimmed goatees that don't compromise the seal usually aren't a problem. The department's grooming policy generally prohibits beards and goatees but provides medical exemptions for employees with certain skin conditions — though those granted exemptions are restricted to light-duty assignments rather than operational work, according to the lawsuit's allegations.
What the Lawsuit Is Asking For
El Omari's lawsuit seeks his reinstatement, unspecified monetary damages, changes to the department's policies governing religious accommodations, and a jury trial. CAIR attorney Aya Beydoun said El Omari should not have had to choose between his religious beliefs and his livelihood, and said the department could have attempted to accommodate his religious practice. Beydoun said El Omari was willing to comply with legitimate workplace safety requirements, but that the department refused to explore any accommodation.
Baltimore's fire department told the Baltimore Sun it could not comment on the allegations or case details because litigation is pending, and did not otherwise comment on the lawsuit when contacted by the paper. This is not the only religious-accommodation dispute the department is facing: paramedic Ariel Rice has separately alleged that the department failed to accommodate his Sabbath and Jewish-holiday observance and disciplined him after faith-conflicting missed shifts, according to the Fire Law Blog. Rice's complaint says the department denied his Rosh Hashanah accommodation request on October 2, 2024, offering shift-swapping or vacation time instead.
Religious-accommodation disputes in emergency medical services extend beyond Baltimore. Emergency services provider Global Medical Response recently agreed to pay $2.2 million and create a new category of nonemergency jobs to resolve a separate EEOC suit, according to Law360. El Omari's case now joins that broader landscape of EMS providers facing scrutiny over how they balance safety equipment rules with workers' religious practices.









