
A South Carolina Criminal Justice Academy Council vote has followed a hearing officer’s recommendation to remove misconduct references from former Charleston County sheriff’s deputy Stuart Prettel II’s record. The decision is separate from Prettel’s civil lawsuit, filed Nov. 17, which alleges wrongful termination and retaliation under South Carolina’s whistleblower protections, as well as threats, coerced statements and missing video evidence.
Prettel alleges he was fired for reporting legal and conduct violations within the Charleston County Sheriff’s Office and raising concerns about investigative supervisors. He contends his termination violated the state whistleblower act, which protects public employees who report government wrongdoing in good faith from retaliation. The Post and Courier reported that Prettel also claims investigators threatened him during interviews and pressured him to write statements he did not want in his file.
The lawsuit describes two civilian complaints that led to internal investigations of Prettel in 2025. One, filed in April, accused him of pushing open a doorway during warrant service, causing an elderly woman to fall, and of unlawfully entering a house. The Post and Courier reported that an internal affairs lieutenant later told Prettel he had been cleared in that matter. The suit also alleges that tensions developed between Prettel and then-Capt. Ryan Kelly, chief inspector with the sheriff’s Office of Professional Standards.
A Vehicle Seizure That Spiraled
The second investigation followed a complaint about an off-duty assignment Prettel was working for another agency. According to the lawsuit, he encountered a vehicle released days earlier after a Charleston County Sheriff’s Office pursuit. After seeking guidance from CCSO superiors, he seized the vehicle and its occupants’ cellphones. The vehicle’s owner accused him of harassment.
Prettel says he gave internal affairs investigators recordings from his body-worn and patrol-vehicle cameras. The lawsuit alleges investigators watched only six of the 16 videos and that all the files were deleted in July 2026. It also accuses William Martin of lying about whether Prettel’s patrol vehicle had an in-car camera.
Internal affairs investigators found Prettel untruthful and imposed a five-day suspension, according to the lawsuit. Human resources rejected his complaint about the interview practices, and the finding remained in his personnel file into 2026. Sheriff Carl Ritchie later overturned it. Records cited in the case say Kelly’s investigation followed a formal complaint and examined alleged misconduct, harassment, improper procedures and unsatisfactory performance.
Threats, Insubordination Claims and a Firing
Prettel alleges that a recording device was turned off at the end of an internal affairs interview with Kelly, who then threatened him. He was also accused of insubordination after seeking advice from the Ninth Circuit Solicitor’s Office about Kelly’s conduct and past investigative practices.
In September 2025, Prettel filed an internal affairs complaint accusing Kelly of abusing his authority, misusing investigative processes and creating a hostile, threatening workplace, the lawsuit says. It alleges the sheriff’s office took no meaningful action and did not interview Prettel about the complaint. He was fired on Nov. 21, 2025, and claims Kelly’s investigations and his efforts to seek outside guidance led to his dismissal.
The lawsuit further alleges that Undersheriff Tyrone Simmons told Prettel a grievance would be futile because it would go to the sheriff who made the firing decision, and that General Counsel Eddie Phipps warned grieving the termination would make matters worse. Prettel says those statements, along with Kelly’s investigative tactics, discouraged him from challenging his firing and amounted to civil conspiracy. The suit says Kelly reported Prettel’s termination to the Criminal Justice Academy on Jan. 16, 2026, alleging misconduct. State law requires agencies to report officer misconduct to the academy within 15 days of the final agency or department action resulting from the internal investigation.
Academy Council Clears Misconduct Finding
At the Academy Council’s Monday meeting, members voted unanimously to follow a hearing officer’s recommendation to expunge Prettel’s separation-due-to-misconduct document and remove misconduct references from his record. Separately, the lawsuit alleges the sheriff’s office sent other agencies a copy of Prettel’s personnel file without his awards and commendations, costing him job opportunities.
What the Academy’s misconduct process covers
The South Carolina Criminal Justice Academy distinguishes an agency-issued law enforcement commission from certification issued through the Law Enforcement Training Council, the state-level credential addressed by its misconduct process. The Academy’s published text of S.C. Code Section 23-23-150(M) says the Council must expunge misconduct-allegation records within 30 days if an officer is found not guilty or not at fault.
Prettel’s attorney, Paul Porter, said he was confident in the allegations and looked forward to discovery and the court process, but declined to say whether Prettel’s complaints about Kelly prompted Kelly’s own termination. Kelly, the Office of Professional Standards’ chief inspector, was terminated June 8; separation paperwork described the reason as an agency-policy violation that did not constitute misconduct as defined by statute, according to a separate Post and Courier report. The sheriff’s office has declined to comment on pending litigation in previous requests. Its general counsel’s office called records related to Kelly’s investigation privileged and refused to release them. A sheriff’s office spokesperson did not respond to the Post and Courier by publication, which also reported it had not received Prettel’s personnel-file documents, requested through the S.C. Criminal Justice Academy, before publication.
Not an Isolated Complaint Nationally
Prettel’s allegations come amid other retaliation lawsuits involving sheriff’s offices in the region, though those separate cases do not establish a broader pattern or prove his claims. In North Carolina, a former Mecklenburg County detention officer sued Sheriff Garry McFadden, alleging she was fired after reporting repeated sexual harassment by a male superior, including Captain Anthony Durrah, in March 2023, according to the Charlotte Observer. She was fired that November after an administrative hearing by an internal board. A former Catawba County deputy also sued, alleging command staff retaliated after she reported another officer’s misconduct and that supervisors scrutinized her more while shielding that officer from consequences, per Queen City News.









