
Five members of the San Antonio City Council are pushing to create a permanent, year-round committee to scrutinize city spending, just months after the council approved the city's first property tax rate increase since the mid-1990s. Council members Marc Whyte, Sukh Kaur, Edward Mungia, Misty Spears and Alderete Gavito signed a memo on November 10 seeking a special council meeting to vote on forming the new budget and finance committee.
The push for tighter financial oversight comes as San Antonio works through the fallout of a rocky FY 2027 budget cycle. According to KENS 5, city staff had projected a budget deficit of $157.7 million by 2028, prompting the council to eventually approve roughly $38 million in reductions along with 150 new or modified city fees. Councilman Jalen McKee-Rodriguez told the outlet the final result pleased none of the council members, while Whyte had opposed raising property taxes back in September.
The memo requests that a special meeting be held no later than December 3. Whyte, who proposed a five-member budget and finance committee, wants it created by the end of this year and meeting at least every other month starting in January, per KENS 5's reporting. He has said he believes a standing panel could improve how the council reviews spending, and he expects it to assess budget scenarios directly with city staff rather than waiting for the annual budget season.
What the Proposed Committee Would Actually Do
Under the plan described to KENS 5, the committee would track whether reforms the council has already adopted are actually being implemented, rather than letting them quietly stall between budget cycles. Any changes it identifies would still require a full council vote, meaning the panel itself would hold no unilateral spending authority. Separately, a search snippet from Texas Public Radio confirms that five council members are proposing a new committee to review spending and identify savings year-round following the tax increase, though the outlet's report did not detail the committee's structure or powers.
Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones told KENS 5 that a budget-focused committee could help rebuild community trust, but only if it is not performative, adding that the city needs a more strategic approach to reviewing expenses and offsets. Normally, the council discusses funding priorities in May or June, with budget details for the current cycle first taken up on August 13, according to the station's report. Under state law, the council must finalize the next fiscal year's budget by the end of September, and the city's fiscal year begins October 1.
A Tax Hike 34 Years in the Making
The budget fight that preceded this proposal was contentious. The council voted 7-4 in September to raise the city's tax rate for the first time since 1992, according to KSAT. The first proposed increase, a 3.9% bump, was estimated to cost the average homestead with a taxable value of $231,356 about $49 more than if the rate had stayed flat, KSAT reported. The station described the pair of increases together as expected to raise the city's rate by roughly 8.5% overall, while the San Antonio Current put the two-year increase at about 8.4% to close what it reported as a $158 million deficit.
Before the vote, Mayor Ortiz Jones had floated a 1.6% cut across all city departments as an alternative to raising property taxes, the Current reported. Whyte pushed his own competing plan to slash spending by 2% at every department. The paper also reported that more than 65% of the proposed budget went toward public safety, including costs tied to the police union contract — a figure that helps explain why council members found so little room to maneuver without touching taxes or fees. The council is expected to consider another property tax rate increase in 2027, according to KENS 5.
Nonprofits Still Bracing for Cuts
The budget debate has hit nonprofit groups especially hard. KENS 5 reported that BioMed and DreamWeek already lost some city funding, and that dozens of nonprofits face more than $5 million in combined delegate-agency funding losses by 2028. Big Brothers Big Sisters of South Texas, which runs on a budget of roughly $4 million, stands to lose its $163,000 city allocation in 2028, per the station's reporting.
Those losses are not new concerns. Nonprofit groups rallied outside San Antonio City Hall in early September, and representatives and supporters of more than 50 organizations pushed back against a proposed $5.1 million reduction, as reported at the time by Texas Public Radio. The station reported that the cut would affect 48 programs serving more than 9,300 residents across all 10 council districts, and Councilman Edward Mungia said 70% of the people who would be dropped from those programs live in districts one through five.
At that September rally, Mayor Ortiz Jones suggested the city look at Ready to Work funds and hotel occupancy tax revenue as possible support for nonprofit services, telling attendees, “Let's use some of that ready-to-work money. … Let's also use some of that hotel occupancy tax,” according to Texas Public Radio. The outlet also reported that the Nonprofit Council said the city's proposed FY 2027 budget maintains significant Department of Human Services funding for nonprofit delegate agencies, even as the deeper FY 2028 cuts loomed.
Per KENS 5's reporting, Denise Barkhurst said any closer budget review should weigh nonprofits' return on investment, the populations they serve, and the long-term costs of scaling back preventive services. Renee Garvens said earlier engagement with nonprofits would elevate budget discussions from the start rather than leaving them to react after decisions are made. The station also reported that the Nonprofit Council has met with city and county leaders to advocate for a commission that would formally structure how nonprofits communicate with officials going forward.









