
Franklin Township officials in York County are weighing whether to walk away from Northern York County Regional Fire and Rescue, a move that could reshape emergency coverage for thousands of residents while township leaders say they are simply trying to protect taxpayers from a looming bill increase. At the center of the dispute is a proposed fee hike that officials say would cost property owners $140 more per year, and a possible switch to a different fire company altogether.
A Budget Fight With Real Stakes For Residents
Leaders in Franklin Township are discussing a plan to drop fire service from Northern York County Regional Fire and Rescue, according to FOX43. The proposed budget would increase service fees not just for Franklin Township but also for Carroll Township and Dillsburg, all of which rely on the regional department. Township officials said the proposal would increase local taxes by $140 per property owner per year, a figure that has become the flashpoint of the debate.
Officials also discussed signing a coverage agreement with York Springs Fire Company as a potential alternative, per the same report. Franklin Township Supervisor David Buckwash framed the discussion around fiscal duty, saying, “We have a financial responsibility to see that the Franklin Township taxpayers' monies are being spent wisely.” On the other side, NYCFR Chief Hector Morales said the budget proposal was meant to address increasing costs for staff and equipment, not to pad the department's bottom line.
Residents Worry About Slower Response Times
The financial debate has not been abstract for residents who showed up to weigh in. Some expressed concern that the township's plan would increase wait times for emergency services, a worry fire officials share for a different reason: they fear the funding shift could push Northern York County Fire and Rescue toward dissolving altogether, the station's report notes.
A former Franklin Township supervisor warned that walking away now could cost far more later. “If it goes paid, you're buying a new building, you're buying new equipment,” the former supervisor said, according to the same account, pointing out that if the volunteer-based service collapses and the township ends up needing a paid department of its own, it would be on the hook for facilities and apparatus it does not currently have to fund directly.
What Northern York County Fire and Rescue Covers
Northern York County Fire & Rescue describes its role as covering fire prevention, fire suppression and emergency medical support across the region, according to the department's own service description. Per the department, its coverage area spans Dillsburg Borough, Franklin Township, Carroll Township and parts of Washington Township — the same municipalities now caught up in the fee dispute.
The tension is not new. Franklin Township's meeting minutes from July 2025 noted that NYCFR had looked into having a fully paid staff but determined it was not feasible at the time, a detail that helps explain why the department is now asking municipalities to help cover rising costs instead.
A Statewide Squeeze on Volunteer Fire Departments
Franklin Township's standoff is unfolding against a broader backdrop of financial strain on Pennsylvania's firefighting system. At a state Senate committee hearing in June, State Fire Commissioner Thomas Cook said rising equipment costs have placed the firefighting force in “crisis” across Pennsylvania, as reported by PennLive. Harrisburg Fire Chief Brian Enterline told the same hearing that new fire trucks typically now take three to five years to be delivered, and that a ladder truck his department bought for $932,000 in 2014 would now cost more than $2 million to replace.
The volunteer pipeline has been shrinking for decades. A 2018 state House report found Pennsylvania's number of volunteer firefighters had dropped 90% since the 1970s, PennLive reported, while the International Association of Fire Fighters has said three manufacturers — REV Group, Oshkosh and Rosenbauer — now control two-thirds of the national fire apparatus market, driving up prices further. Nationally, the U.S. has lost about a quarter of its volunteer firefighters since 2008 even as call volume rose roughly 70%, according to WITF.
Pennsylvania's volunteer ranks have stabilized in recent years at roughly 32,000 to 35,000, per the Office of the State Fire Commissioner, and the state has responded with $30 million in competitive grant funding for fire stations, a bill that passed the state House 105-96 with backing from Gov. Josh Shapiro. WITF reported that the same office is pushing the $30 million in grants to help municipalities with regionalization or staffing, though officials have cautioned it is not a long-term fix. Other departments have already made the jump to paid staff: Lower Paxton Township's Colonial Park, Paxtonia and Linglestown fire companies first hired paid firefighters in September 2025, growing to 20 career staff working alongside volunteers after finding their three stations would have been adequately staffed just 17% of the time in the first half of 2026 without the added help.
Both Sides Say They're Still Talking
Despite the sharp disagreement over cost, township leaders and NYCFR officials say they intend to keep negotiating. Both sides say they will continue to work toward an agreement before the township budget is passed in December, FOX43 reported. A NYCFR official said the department is waiting to receive the comments from the municipality before doing one last scrub through the budget if necessary, leaving the door open for a revised proposal before any final decision is made.









