New York City/ Crime & Emergencies

Freehold School Staff Log 80 Injuries This Year, Vote No Confidence In Superintendent

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Freehold School Staff Log 80 Injuries This Year, Vote No Confidence In SuperintendentSource: Google Street View

Two employee associations in the Freehold Borough school district have voted no confidence in Superintendent Asia Michael, citing concerns that include safety, staffing and leadership. The dispute comes as teacher and union president Stephanie Cholak says staff at Freehold Learning Center have documented 80 injuries this year and police or school security have been called to the building at least 30 times.

NJ.com reported that Cholak’s injury tally covers the period through Nov. 4 and that workers’ compensation claims were filed for three educators with serious injuries. Freehold Learning Center serves students from pre-kindergarten through second grade. The broader Freehold Borough K-8 district has three schools and roughly 1,600 students, according to NJ.com.

Cholak, a science teacher and president of the Freehold Borough Education Association, has said staff are anxious about what she described as preventable violence. Union leaders have cited physical aggression by special and general education students, as well as concerns about Michael’s fiscal decisions, transparency and trust, according to NJ.com.

What the votes show

The teachers’ union and the district’s administrators held separate votes. Among 194 participating members of the Freehold Borough Education Association, 184 supported the no-confidence resolution, five opposed it and five abstained; 38 members did not participate, NJ.com reported. On Oct. 12, seven of the eight members of the Freehold Borough Administrators Association voted no confidence in Michael, with one abstention, according to Jennifer Donnelly, the association’s co-president and the district’s director of technology and assessment. The results record the associations’ views of Michael’s leadership; they do not, on their own, resolve the underlying safety and management concerns.

The Freehold Borough Education Association represents teachers, teacher’s aides, secretaries, nurses, child study team members and custodians. Patch independently reported the vote totals and said the associations cited concerns involving student and staff safety, support services, consistent implementation of district policies, staffing and administrative decision-making. The associations described the ballots as “the results of separate, anonymous votes of no confidence in Superintendent Dr. Asia Michael,” according to Patch.

Staffing and support questions

One resource concern raised by union leaders is that the district has one board-certified behavioral analyst for all three schools, NJ.com reported. Cholak also criticized the school board for expressing solidarity with Michael before hearing from either association, according to the outlet.

Michael, who was hired in 2023 and whose contract runs through June 2027, earns more than $192,000 annually according to state pension records, as reported by NJ.com. She responded to NJ.com by emailing the same statement she had read at a board meeting, saying student and staff safety is her highest priority and that staff deserve safe working conditions. “No employee should be expected to accept injury as part of the job, and every student deserves a safe learning environment,” she said, adding that the district has taken steps “to provide additional classroom support and strengthen our response to our administrators and special services personnel.” The report notes that Michael did not provide specific examples of those added supports.

The board’s response

The Freehold Borough Board of Education said it could not discuss the allegations against Michael because they involve sensitive personnel matters. The board said it had tried to arrange meetings with both unions and that Michael and board members had invited union leaders to discuss their grievances. It expressed full faith and confidence in Michael’s leadership and urged the associations and district leaders to work through their differences. Patch reported that Michael and Board of Education President Joe Santonacita declined to comment to that outlet.

The district’s harassment, intimidation and bullying page provides information about its HIB process. That guidance is separate from the staff-injury tally and the staffing concerns raised in the current dispute.

What state safety data measures

The New Jersey Department of Education’s 2023-24 report found that reported incidents declined across categories and overall violence incidents fell, even as fights increased. The state’s Student Safety Data System tracks student-safety and discipline categories—including violence, vandalism, weapons and substance offenses—and responses such as police notifications and student removals, according to the department’s report and its reporting guidance. Those statewide trends do not establish a Freehold-specific count, and the system’s student-safety categories are distinct from Cholak’s tally of staff injuries.