
More than two decades after Barbara Lee’s body turned up in a dirt field in southwest Fresno, a courtroom is now hearing testimony about DNA evidence that linked Robert Castillo to the case. Prosecutors began laying out their case Wednesday against 61-year-old Robert Castillo, who is accused of murdering the 43-year-old Lee in 2004 and sexually assaulting two other women in separate attacks.
Lee, who also went by Barbara Parker, was found on October 31, 2004, in a field near California and Polk Avenues, according to the Fresno County Sheriff’s Office. Investigators found evidence of sexual assault and significant trauma to Lee, and according to testimony reported by ABC30, she had an unclothed lower body, clothing pulled upward, visible injuries to her left eye, and dirt on her face and genital area. Former Fresno County Sheriff’s homicide detective John Ciaccio, one of the original investigators, testified about the condition of the crime scene when he responded in 2004, the station reported.
A Pager Led Nowhere — Until DNA Caught Up
Detectives recovered a pager at the scene and traced it to a disconnected phone number associated with Castillo, according to ABC30’s account of the testimony. But without a way to confirm the connection at the time, the case went cold after detectives were unable to identify a suspect despite interviewing people close to Lee, including her husband, son and sister-in-law — interviews conducted by special investigator Sergio Toscano, who worked the original homicide investigation and later returned to it as a cold-case investigator. According to testimony, Lee’s sister-in-law confirmed that Lee had struggled with drugs and had been involved in prostitution.
The case sat unresolved for roughly two decades until Fresno County Sheriff’s cold-case investigators received a DNA hit linking Castillo to it in February 2025, per the ABC30 report. The Sheriff’s Office has said evolving DNA technology allowed investigators to compare and confirm samples that matched both Castillo and Lee. Toscano testified that after learning of the match, he tracked Castillo down, and Castillo agreed to come to the Sheriff’s Office to provide fresh DNA swabs — twice, according to the Fresno Bee, which reported that the samples were a match in all three crimes under review.
Arrest Came After 20 Years, Sheriff’s Office Says
Detectives with the Sheriff’s Violent Criminal Apprehension Team were tasked with contacting and arresting Castillo on April 10, 2025, for the murder and sexual assault of Lee, the sheriff’s office said in its release. He was booked into the Fresno County Jail on a charge of murder, two counts of rape and one count of sexual assault, with bail set at $2.1 million, the same statement said. The office’s Cold Case Unit Review Board said it has solved nine cold-case homicides over the past year, including Lee’s case.
The DNA comparisons also produced matches to a 2003 rape case and a 2004 rape case, the sheriff’s office said, adding that another rape case remained pending additional DNA testing. The Fresno Bee reported that Castillo’s “genetic fingerprints” matched evidence from all three victims connected to the case.
Two Women Describe Attacks Decades Ago
Prosecutors called two women who allege Castillo picked them up and drove them to isolated orchard locations before sexually assaulting and beating them, according to the ABC30 report, and they pointed to similarities between those allegations and the circumstances surrounding Lee’s death. One woman, identified in testimony as Jane Doe 2, told the court that after she tried to flee, he chased her down and brought her back to where he had parked, the Fresno Bee reported. She testified that she needed eight stitches to close a cut over her eye.
A second woman testified that Castillo assaulted her near a canal in 2004 and then picked her up by the neck and threw her against a tree, per the Fresno Bee’s account of the hearing. Former Fresno County Sheriff’s detective Jerry Kitchens testified that one of the women was visibly upset when he interviewed her at the time, and he corroborated graphic details she had shared about the alleged assault, according to ABC30. A former sheriff’s employee, Elizabeth Galindo-Edwards, who photographed Lee’s body during the original homicide investigation, was also among those connected to the case’s evidentiary record.
What Comes Next
What Comes Next Testimony is expected to continue Thursday morning, according to ABC30’s reporting on the ongoing hearing. The judge has not yet ordered Castillo to stand trial and is still deciding whether the evidence justifies a jury trial. The hearing so far has centered on testimony and DNA evidence rather than a final determination of guilt, and no outcome of the proceeding has yet been reported.









