
More than a year after a deputy shot and killed Johnny Ray Moore Jr. outside a vacant Greenville County home, the 44-year-old’s brother has filed a lawsuit accusing the deputy of excessive force and the sheriff’s office of negligence. Jeremy Moore, representing his brother’s estate, is suing Deputy David Gonzalez and the Greenville County Sheriff’s Office, alleging Gonzalez shot Moore three times even though he posed no immediate threat.
According to FOX Carolina News, the lawsuit claims Gonzalez responded to a trespassing call on Stegall Circle, pursued Moore after he picked up a hammer, and confronted him without backup or mental health resources. The suit accuses the deputy of excessive force and assault and battery, and names the sheriff’s office in claims of negligence, assault and battery, and negligent training. It seeks damages for financial losses, grief, funeral and burial expenses, alleged suffering, and medical expenses, along with punitive damages, attorney’s fees, costs, and a jury determination of actual and consequential damages, per the same outlet’s report.
What Deputies Said Happened That Sunday
The shooting happened on September 28, 2025, after deputies responded to a trespassing call at a vacant property on Stegall Circle at approximately 12:50 p.m., according to The Post and Courier. The sheriff’s office said a 911 caller stated Moore had previously been trespassed from the home, and WSPA reported he had been placed on trespass notice from the property. The lawsuit also claims a caller warned that Moore wanted police to kill him.
Deputy Gonzalez attempted to arrest Moore upon making contact, and the sheriff’s office said Moore grabbed a hammer while running away. Officials said Gonzalez believed Moore was going to throw the hammer and then fired his gun. The Post and Courier reported the deputy shot Moore three times, while WSPA reported that the coroner determined Moore’s cause of death was one gunshot wound — accounts that have not been reconciled. Moore died at a hospital after being shot, according to the FOX Carolina report.
Conflicting Accounts Of The Hammer
Deputies said Moore raised the hammer in a position from which he could have thrown it, but The Post and Courier separately reported that released footage does not show Moore raising the hammer. That discrepancy remains unresolved in the public record.
Gonzalez was placed on paid administrative leave following the shooting, and an internal review later found his use of force justified, officials said. The deputy has since been taken off paid administrative leave and cleared to return to full duty service, according to a department spokesperson cited by WYFF. The State Law Enforcement Division and the 13th Circuit Solicitor’s Office were expected to continue a third-party investigation into whether Gonzalez’s actions complied with state policies and standards, WYFF reported; the outcome of that review has not been made public.
Part Of A Rising Count For The County
The Post and Courier reported that Moore was the sixth person Greenville County deputies had shot in 2025, and that five of the six had died — a tally that matched the agency’s 2024 figure, according to State Law Enforcement Division data cited by the outlet. A SLED release noted South Carolina recorded 45 officer-involved shootings statewide in 2024.
Under South Carolina law, the Tort Claims Act is described as the exclusive remedy for a tort committed by a government employee acting within the scope of employment, according to the South Carolina Code of Laws, Title 15, Chapter 78. That statute does not by itself establish whether or how it applies to the claims raised in Jeremy Moore’s lawsuit, and the case’s current status, including any response from the defendants, has not been confirmed.









