
Hawaii employers are bracing for another round of higher health insurance bills after the state Insurance Division signed off last week on new rates for every major carrier in the islands. The increases land above inflation across the board, with UHA's approved 19.5% hike now the largest of the bunch, even though HMSA — the insurer covering most of Hawaii's workforce — managed to talk its own request down significantly before the ink dried.
HMSA's Increase Shrinks, But Still Stings
HMSA originally asked for nearly a 20% increase on small employer plans before pulling that number back to about 15%, according to Hawaii News Now. By the time regulators finished their review, the final rate increase for employers with fewer than 50 workers had fallen further, from 14.9% down to 6.3%. Insurance Commissioner Scott Saiki said the retreat happened because reviewers concluded HMSA had been too pessimistic about its own financial outlook, including overestimating expected losses for 2027. “There was an overestimate of estimated losses for the year 2027,” Saiki said.
Dale Goya said HMSA took proactive action to reduce its rates based on a clearer picture of expected costs facing small businesses, the station's report notes. Kaiser Permanente's increase came in at 6%, the lowest of the group, while HMAA's rose 16% and UHA's climbed to 19.5% — the steepest jump among all insurers reviewed, per the same account.
Why One Company's Rate Hike Touches Nearly Everyone
The reason HMSA's number matters so much beyond its own customers comes down to market share. State Representative Scot Matayoshi, a Democrat who chairs the House Consumer Protection & Commerce Committee, estimated HMSA controls at least 70% of the market, meaning its rate decisions ripple across the broader business community. “I think 70% plus,” Matayoshi said, according to the same outlet, adding that HMSA's increases are devastating across the board precisely because of that dominant share.
UHA, for its part, said it held its own rate increases to single digits from 2022 through 2025 while Hawaii recovered from the pandemic, and the company expects its rates to remain the lowest in the state despite the newly approved hike. Consumer and business advocates said they remain alarmed by the overall increases, and Sherry Menor said businesses are increasingly asking how to mitigate the rising cost of health coverage.
What Determines the Final Bill
Not every employer will feel these approved rates the same way. Actual premiums paid by employers and workers depend on each company's claims history and sometimes on direct negotiations with the insurer, the report explains. Saiki said high-risk employer groups should expect to see higher premiums as a result, while the rates overall are structured to let insurers remain solvent and pay claims while still earning roughly a 3% profit.
Under Hawaii law, employers must provide health insurance to employees working at least 20 hours a week and cover at least half of the premium costs, according to Honolulu Civil Beat. That outlet also reported that HMSA had received approval for a 13.8% benchmark rate increase in 2026 before applying for the 14.9% hike for 2027, and that requested 2027 increases statewide ranged from Kaiser Permanente's 6% up to UHA's 19.6% as originally filed.
A Debate Over Opening Hawaii's Market
Matayoshi raised the question of whether more competition might ease the pressure, suggesting that eliminating premium taxes could draw more for-profit mainland insurers into Hawaii. But he cautioned that strong guardrails would be necessary if that tax were lifted and outside insurers allowed to compete. Saiki pushed back against the idea entirely, warning that large national companies might enter the Hawaii market and gouge consumers. He said he had heard complaints about mainland providers raising rates while denying large numbers of claims.
The pressure on Hawaii's system reflects a trend playing out nationally. KITV reported that health-care costs were rising by an average of 10% for roughly half a million Hawaii residents covered through HMSA employer plans, describing the double-digit increases as reflecting a years-long trend of spiking medical costs. Nationally, an analysis from the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker found the median proposed premium increase among 295 small-group insurers across all 50 states and Washington, D.C. was 14% for 2027, with the median insurer estimate of underlying health-care cost growth at 10.8%. Insurers in Michigan have pointed to similar pressures, with regulators there approving average 2027 increases of 14.2% for individual plans and 9.6% for small-group plans, as reported by the Detroit Free Press, which noted insurers generally cited higher use of medical services and rising prescription drug prices.
Some experts have warned that rising health costs, an aging population and a shrinking share of younger people paying into the system could eventually push the current insurance model toward collapse, potentially forcing a shift toward much larger government programs. For now, Hawaii employers and workers are left watching how the newly approved rates translate into their own premiums, a figure that regulators say still hinges on each company's individual claims record.









