
Hawthorne's governing body sent a pointed message to its garbage hauler this week, voting 4-3 against approving a roughly $95,100 payment to Affordable Cartage LLC following months of complaints over missed pickups. The vote came during the council's meeting on Monday, but officials were quick to stress that trash and recycling collection would continue without interruption.
The decision to withhold the payment stemmed from what officials described as months of resident complaints about the new garbage and recycling company, along with the borough's own follow-up, according to TAPinto Hawthorne. Affordable Cartage took over Hawthorne's garbage, recycling and yard waste collection services in April, after the borough awarded the company a four-year contract at its Feb. 18 meeting covering solid waste, Type 10 and 13 recyclables, yard waste and bagged leaves, according to contract records published by the Borough of Hawthorne. That contract, which runs from April 1, 2026 through March 31, 2030, is valued at $5,476,190, the same borough documents show.
Complaints Mounted for Months Before the Vote
During the meeting, officials discussed missed streets, trucks arriving too early, and repeated efforts to get the company to improve service. Council Vice President Mike Sciarra said borough officials had repeatedly met with the company about service complaints and had summoned company representatives multiple times to discuss the issues, the report notes. Sciarra argued the contractor had had sufficient time to address recurring service problems.
Council President Frank Matthews reported that recycling collection in his district had been missed for several days. Councilman Joseph Wojtecki raised separate concerns that garbage collections had begun before permitted hours, and the article notes that Affordable Cartage reportedly received a summons over collections beginning before the permitted time. A separate TAPinto headline referenced in the outlet's archive put it plainly: garbage pickups before 7 a.m. violate the contract, according to Hawthorne officials.
A Split Council, a Warning From the Borough Attorney
Not every council member backed withholding the full payment. Councilwoman Anna Marie Sasso said she supported approving the bill while asking the administration to delay actual payment until complaints were addressed, expressing concern both about the contractor's performance and about the consequences of withholding payment outright. Sasso said the contractor should face a consequence for its poor work, but she wanted that consequence to stop short of nonpayment.
Borough Attorney Michael Pasquale warned that withholding the roughly $95,000 payment could lead to a contract dispute or a service interruption, and he questioned whether withholding the entire bill was an appropriate remedy, per the same account. Pasquale said the decision of whether to withhold payment ultimately rested with the council, not his office. Sciarra suggested the council could reconsider payment at its next meeting if the company made the necessary improvements.
What the Vote Did and Didn't Change
The 4-3 vote did not cancel the borough's contract with Affordable Cartage, and the council approved the remaining payments on its agenda that night. The disputed payment remains unapproved while officials press the company to address the complaints, and Hawthorne officials announced that there would be no interruption to garbage or recycling collection despite the standoff over the bill.
Earlier reporting from TAPinto Hawthorne in July described residents reporting missed trash pickups and a poor response from the new hauler, suggesting the frustration aired at this week's meeting had been building for months. Affordable Cartage's bid for the contract came in roughly $3 million below the next-lowest bidder, a figure officials have cited as representing substantial taxpayer savings even as the service problems have persisted.









