Capital Region/ Real Estate & Development

Hoffman's Playland Site Eyes 150-Unit Senior Complex, 26 Memory-Care Beds; Height Still a Sticking Point

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Hoffman's Playland Site Eyes 150-Unit Senior Complex, 26 Memory-Care Beds; Height Still a Sticking PointSenior Living Community Courtyard
James Day / Unsplash

The shuttered Hoffman's Playland site on Loudon Road in Loudonville could soon become home to 150 units of senior housing and 26 memory-care beds, after Montgomery Street Partners pitched a revised plan featuring a five-story independent living building, a three-story assisted living building and a one-story memory care building. The proposal marks the latest attempt to find new life for the beloved amusement park's old footprint, more than a decade after it shut its gates for good.

Montgomery Street Partners, described by the Times Union as a Texas-based commercial real estate and private equity firm, is proposing three buildings at 606 and 608 Loudon Road in Loudonville. According to reporting from Ethan Agee, a University at Albany journalism student participating in the SUNY Institute for Local News Initiative, the complex would include a five-story independent living apartment building with 100 units, a three-story assisted living building with 50 units, and a one-story memory care building with 26 beds. The entire development will be rental, with independent living apartments including full kitchens, meals, utilities, activities and transportation built into the rent, while assisted living units offer smaller apartments along with meals, housekeeping, laundry and medication management. The memory care building is intended to provide specialized care for residents with cognitive impairments.

A Scaled-Back Vision for a Long-Vacant Property

The site has sat empty since 2014, when owners Dave and Ruth Hoffman retired and closed the amusement park, as The Daily Gazette reports. The town approved an original planned development district plan in 2020, which included a 26,000-square-foot retail and residential building along Route 9 in addition to the senior housing. That original approval also came with a $500,000 contribution toward sidewalks along Route 9 and a traffic study requested by nearby residents.

Andy Brick, the developers' legal representative, said the $500,000 contribution was never finalized because the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted the project shortly after approval. Developers remain prepared to provide that same contribution under the revised plan, per Brick. He also said additional wetlands concerns required a redesign that removes the retail building entirely and moves the senior living complex closer to Route 9, replacing the original two-building plan of a retail building and a senior living facility with a senior-living-focused development.

Planning Board Weighs In on Height and Traffic

The Planning Board reviewed the changes to the development plan on October 20, 2026, and responded favorably to much of the proposal, including its architecture and the additional senior housing options it would bring to the area. But board members also raised questions about the height of the largest building, traffic circulation, parking and the public benefit the project would provide.

The five-story independent living building will reach about 58 feet at the roofline, with architectural features extending above that, before stepping down to three stories and then one story toward the rear of the property. Kevin Bronner Jr. questioned whether a five-story building so close to Route 9 would set a precedent for future development elsewhere in Colonie. Steven Heider echoed that worry, saying he was not against the project outright but was not enthusiastic about five stories directly on Route 9, and raised concern about what precedent it might set for other projects down the road. Not every board member shared that hesitation — Barlette and JoAnn Maloy both voiced support for the proposed building height.

Traffic Engineer Says Revised Plan Means Fewer Trips

Wendy Holsberger, the project's traffic engineer, told the board the revised project would generate substantially less traffic than the original proposal. The development is expected to generate approximately 35 vehicle trips during the morning peak hour and approximately 45 vehicle trips during the afternoon peak hour. Brick said the revised project is smaller for traffic purposes specifically because one building — the retail and restaurant component — was eliminated from the plan.

Town planning staff indicated that the question of public benefit, including whether the sidewalk contribution or other commitments will satisfy the town, would be revisited during concept review. Architectural plans submitted so far include two landscaped courtyards, one designed as a resident gathering and activity space and another intended as quieter outdoor space near the memory care building. The site plan also calls for landscaped parking islands, shade trees and plantings along Route 9.

Honoring the Site's History

Several Planning Board members urged the developers to include some form of historical commemoration of the former amusement park within the new complex. Henry Rosenzweig specifically suggested a historical commemorative feature be built into the development, a nod to generations of local families who visited Hoffman's Playland over the years — including Elaine Regilski and her granddaughter Kate Regilski, who were photographed riding the Scrambler there in June 2013, not long before the park's closing.

David Hoffman, the former Hoffman's Playland owner who still owns one of the two parcels that make up the site, said finding an appropriate use for the property had long been a goal for his family. He and his family wanted a development that would leave a legacy for their community, according to the reporting.

Developers Point to Local Demand

Kelly Andress, a senior living executive and partner at Montgomery Street Partners, said the area is underserved by independent living, assisted living and memory care facilities. Paul Leo similarly said independent living, assisted living and memory care options were needed in the area, backing up the developers' rationale for the project's focus on senior housing rather than retail.

The Hoffman's Playland site isn't the only stretch of Loudon Road to see a senior-housing pitch in recent years. New Loudon Realty Company, LLC brought a separate concept to the Colonie Planning Board in March 2021 for 606 and 608 Loudon Road, calling for a four-story, 85-unit senior independent living building, a three-story, 92-bed senior assisted living building, and a 26,000-square-foot retail or restaurant building, according to Town of Colonie Planning Board records. It remains a useful point of comparison for how senior housing has been pitched along the same corridor, though it was an entirely separate proposal from the current Hoffman's Playland plan.

The Hoffman's Playland property was rezoned in 2020 to allow for mixed-use development, but the path since then has not been straightforward. The DEC denied an original wetlands permit application in 2023 because the plan at the time did not include an alternative proposal to limit environmental impacts, per the Times Union. Developers still need to secure a Wetlands Disturbance Permit from the DEC before final plans can be approved, even though the revised design is intended to avoid direct impacts to the wetland itself.