Washington, D.C./ Politics & Govt

ICC Judges Close Part of Afghanistan Probe That Touched US Troops

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 15, 2026
ICC Judges Close Part of Afghanistan Probe That Touched US TroopsInternational Criminal Court — Court Behind Closure Decision
Google Street View

International Criminal Court judges have formally closed part of the prosecutor's long-running Afghanistan investigation, the track that once examined alleged crimes by U.S. troops and the Islamic State-Khorasan militia, while leaving the door open on a narrower case focused on the Taliban. The decision does not end scrutiny of Afghanistan entirely, and the ICC's prosecutor's office has already appealed it.

What the Court Actually Decided

According to the Raleigh News & Observer, ICC judges decided to formally close part of the prosecutor's Afghanistan investigations, limiting the remaining focus to alleged Taliban actions since 2021. The original inquiry had included allegations involving U.S. troops as well as a probe into the Islamic State-Khorasan militia, known as IS-K. Judges said prosecutors had not shown they could effectively investigate those other allegations separately from the Taliban-focused case, per the same report.

The court's Afghanistan page concerns the Situation of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. The decision was issued on Nov. 12 and made public on Nov. 13. The closure decision concerns that situation, distinct from the separate Situation in Afghanistan II. The record-closure decision is also subject to appeal.

Two Tracks, One Case Split in Two

ICC judges had ordered prosecutors to split the Afghanistan inquiries into two separate probes this year, the News & Observer reports. The first probe focuses on alleged crimes committed by the Taliban since 2021, while the second encompasses the original Afghanistan inquiry, including alleged war crimes by U.S. troops and IS-K. A joint civil-society statement adds further detail on how that split came about: on July 15, Pre-Trial Chamber II directed the Office of the Prosecutor to open a separate investigation based on a six-state referral from November 2024, according to the statement published by ahrdo.org.

That same statement says the chamber rejected the prosecutor's requests for clarification and reconsideration, reaffirming its direction on Sept. 3. The maneuvering reflects years of tension inside the court over how broadly to pursue allegations tied to the conflict. Middle East Eye reported that the broader Afghanistan inquiry concerned alleged war crimes committed since 2003 by Afghan National Security Forces, U.S. military and CIA personnel, the Taliban, and IS-K, according to Middle East Eye.

A Years-Old Narrowing Under Prosecutor Khan

The current split isn't the first time the U.S.-related strand of the case was sidelined. Middle East Eye also reported that in 2021, prosecutor Karim Khan deprioritized the portion of the probe concerning U.S. military and CIA personnel as well as former Afghan government forces, choosing instead to focus the investigation on the Taliban and IS-K. The outlet's reporting on Afghanistan arrest warrants has since been confirmed by the court.

Arrest warrants remain in effect for four Afghan Taliban leaders, the News & Observer notes. The ICC's founding statute allows prosecution of anyone accused of atrocity crimes committed on the territory of ICC member states, and closing part of the Afghanistan case does not change that founding statute, the outlet reports.

Appeal Filed, Sanctions in the Background

The ICC prosecutor's office has appealed the decision to close part of the Afghanistan investigation, the News & Observer reports, but it declined to provide further details about that appeal. The evidence available does not establish what the appeal will ultimately decide.

The case unfolds against a backdrop of U.S. pressure on the court. The United States has issued institutional sanctions against the ICC, citing opposition to arrest warrants for Israeli officials as well as the investigation into U.S. soldiers' actions in Afghanistan, according to the News & Observer. Middle East Eye separately reported that since February 2025, the U.S. has imposed retaliatory financial and visa sanctions on court officials connected to the Afghanistan and Palestine investigations.

The underlying Afghanistan case traces back more than a decade on the ground. U.S. Army soldiers patrolled Chariagen village in Kandahar province's Panjwai district on June 22, 2011, according to the News & Observer, an episode tied to the broader allegations the court has examined over the years. Reporting on the latest developments was filed from The Hague by Reuters' Stephanie van den Berg, where the International Criminal Court is based.