
An Idaho Fish and Game commissioner has agreed to plead guilty to two misdemeanor hunting charges stemming from a December 2025 poaching investigation, while prosecutors drop five other counts against him under the proposed deal. Brody Harshbarger, who represents the Upper Snake Region in eastern Idaho, will admit to hunting without a valid tag and shooting from or across a public highway.
According to probable-cause documents cited by the Idaho Capital Sun, Harshbarger shot from the driver's seat of his vehicle, and he and another hunter fired across Spring Hollow Road. The case traces back to a Citizens Against Poaching hotline call that a Fish and Game officer responded to on December 20, 2025, which ultimately led to seven hunting, poaching and trespassing charges against the commissioner.
Under the reported agreement, described by Boise State Public Radio, the state will dismiss five other misdemeanor charges, including poaching and hunting from a vehicle, in exchange for the guilty pleas. The proposed penalties call for revoking Harshbarger's hunting privileges for one year, a $500 fine per charge, and six months of probation. Harshbarger had initially pleaded not guilty to all seven counts against him.
Sentencing Set for December, Outcome Still Pending
Harshbarger is scheduled to appear before a Fremont County judge for sentencing on December 9, according to the same station's report. Because that hearing has not yet occurred, it remains unresolved whether the proposed penalties will ultimately be imposed as described.
Harshbarger has not resigned his commission seat. A March 10 letter from Governor Brad Little's chief of staff said Harshbarger agreed to postpone performing his commissioner duties while the criminal charges remained unresolved, per the Idaho Capital Sun. A spokesperson for Little told the outlet that Harshbarger continued to serve as a commissioner and that the governor had not asked for his resignation.
A Governor's Appointee Facing a Rare Test
Little first appointed Harshbarger to the commission in 2024 to represent the Upper Snake Region, and his term is scheduled to run through June 2027, according to the Idaho Statesman. The case has drawn comparisons to a previous commissioner controversy: in 2018, Southwest Region Commissioner Blake Fischer resigned amid intense criticism after photographing himself with baboons he had shot on an African hunting trip, the Statesman notes.
The case also lands amid a record number of calls about illegal wildlife-related activity to Idaho's Citizens Against Poaching hotline. Idaho's Citizens Against Poaching hotline received 1,596 calls about illegal wildlife-related activity in 2025, the highest annual total since tracking began in 2019, according to Outdoor Life. Harshbarger's case began with exactly that kind of hotline tip.
For now, the central questions in the case remain open. It is not yet established whether Harshbarger has formally entered his pleas, whether he will be sentenced as proposed, or whether he will resume his commissioner duties once the charges are resolved.









