
Islip's proposed 2027 budget would raise the town's property-tax levy by nearly 12%, pushing a typical $400,000 home's tax bill from $772 this year to $907 next year. The $306.5 million spending plan has split the town board, with Supervisor Angie Carpenter's motion to approve it dying for lack of a second at a recent meeting.
A Levy That Blows Past the State Cap
According to Newsday, the proposed budget totals $306.5 million, about $18 million or 6% more than this year's spending. The tax levy itself would climb to $177.9 million from $159.2 million, an increase of nearly 12% that would surpass Islip's 2% state tax cap. If adopted as proposed, it would mark the third consecutive year the town has pierced that cap.
Comptroller Robert Kordic attributed $15.2 million of the new spending to health insurance, pension costs, union salary increases, a new garbage contract, and higher debt-service payments, the outlet reported. Fire Island News also reported that Kordic said the budget protects the town's AAA bond rating.
Board Fractures Over Process, Not Just Numbers
At the November 5 public hearing, Carpenter moved to adopt the proposed budget, but the motion died without a second backer. Councilman Michael McElwee said he opposed the plan because Carpenter had excluded board members from the budget process, and he argued that the failure to advance the budget showed the process itself needs to change. McElwee also made clear that supporting the town's ability to pierce the tax cap does not mean automatically supporting the budget Carpenter put forward.
Carpenter pushed back, saying board members had the proposed budget since September 15 and had ample opportunity to weigh in. Her office has said department heads were available to answer budget questions, and that no changes were ultimately offered by board members during that window. Councilman John Lorenzo declined to support the proposed budget, citing an affordability crisis among residents and saying families and seniors need no additional tax increase amid rising costs of necessities.
Who Voted to Pierce the Cap in the First Place
The divide traces back to September, when four council members, Carpenter, McElwee, and Democratic Councilman Jorge Guadrón, voted to pierce the 2027 tax cap, while Republican Councilwoman DawnMarie Kuhn voted against doing so, Newsday reported. That vote cleared the way for the levy increase now before the board, even as members disagree on the budget built around it.
A Deadline Bearing Down on the Board
The town board has until November 20 to approve a 2027 spending plan. Otherwise, under state law, the proposed budget would be automatically adopted without further board action, Newsday reported. The next town board meeting is scheduled for November 17 at Islip Town Hall, with streaming options available, ahead of that deadline.
Part of a Broader Suffolk Pattern
Islip's push to exceed its cap is not isolated. Farrell Fritz noted that Islip pierced the cap for a second straight year in 2026, and that seven of Suffolk County's ten town boards were set to vote on resolutions to do the same that year. Nearby, Southampton Town adopted its own 2027 budget of $155.1 million, raising spending by nearly 8.2% and its tax levy by 10.5%, exceeding the state cap as well, according to a separate Newsday report. Southampton officials estimated that increase would add about $159 to annual town tax bills for a home valued around $1.65 million, after board members amended Supervisor Maria Moore's initial proposal to add six jobs and fund capital improvements.
The pattern reflects a statewide trend. The Office of the New York State Comptroller reported that a growing number of local governments have told the agency they plan to override the property-tax cap in recent years, state Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli's office said.
Fire Island News, which reported on the Islip board's internal rift, reported that the town board rejected its 2026 budget and failed to pass an alternative before the state deadline last year, meaning the supervisor's proposal took effect by default, as Fire Island News reported. With the board again divided over the 2027 plan, Islip risks repeating that outcome if no agreement is reached before November 20.









